In the Shade of the Qur'an by Sayyid Qutb

This sūrah, Al-Isrā’, or The Night Journey, was revealed whilst the Prophet lived in Makkah. It begins with glorifying God and ends with praising Him. It includes a number of themes, most of which directly relate to the issue of faith, but some tackle certain aspects of individual and social behaviour and its moral basis of faith. It also includes stories about the Children of Israel relevant to the Aqşā Mosque, the Prophet’s terrestrial destination on his night journey, as well as some aspects of the story of Adam and Satan, and the honour God has granted to mankind.

However, the most prominent element in the sūrah and its central point is the Prophet himself (peace be upon him). It examines the attitude adopted by the people of Makkah to him, as well as the message he preached, embodied in the Qur’ān, and the guidance it provides and how the unbelievers received it. This leads to a discussion about the nature of the message and the role of God’s messengers. It points to the distinction of the Prophet’s message by virtue of it having no physical, preternatural phenomenon to support it. It has been God’s will that when such a phenomenon, or miracle, was formerly given in support of a divine message, those who continued to deny the message were shortly destroyed in consequence. It also states the principle of individual responsibility in matters of faith, guidance and error, and collective responsibility in matters of social behaviour. However all such responsibility applies after God has made His message clear to mankind through prophets and messengers whose task is to advise, warn and give sound counsel, and also to make everything clear: “Most clearly have We spelled out everything.” (Verse 12)

The sūrah repeatedly praises God and glorifies Him and mentions the need to praise and thank Him for all the blessings He bestows on His servants. It begins with glorifying Him: “Limitless in His glory is He who transported His servant by night from the Sacred Mosque [in Makkah] to the Aqşā Mosque [in Jerusalem]...” (Verse 1) Soon afterwards, the Children of Israel are commanded to believe in God’s oneness and are reminded that they belong to the offspring of Noah who was ‘a truly grateful servant of Ours.’ (Verse 3) When the unbelievers’ claims about their false deities are mentioned, the sūrah comments: “Limitless is He in His glory and sublimely exalted is He above everything they may say [about Him]. The seven heavens extol His limitless glory, as does the earth, and all who dwell in them. Indeed every single thing extols His glory and praise, but you cannot understand their praises. He is indeed Forbearing, Much Forgiving.” (Verses 43-44) The sūrah quotes some of the people of earlier divine religions who say when the Qur’ān is recited to them: “Limitless in His glory is our Lord! Truly has the promise of our Lord been fulfilled.” (Verse 108) The last verse in the sūrah states: “And say, All praise is due to God who has never begotten a son; who has no partner in His dominion; who needs none to support Him against any difficulty.’ And extol His greatness.” (Verse 111)

Thus the sūrah revolves around one axis although it tackles several subjects. Its first part mentions the night journey: “Limitless in His glory is He who transported His servant by night from the Sacred Mosque [in Makkah] to the Aqşā Mosque [in Jerusalem] — the environs of which We have blessed.” (Verse 1) It also specifies the purpose of this journey:

“so that We might show him some of Our signs.” (Verse 1) In connection with the mosque in Jerusalem the sūrah mentions the hook revealed to Moses and what God determined in it for the Children of Israel, speaking about two episodes of destruction and diaspora because of their injustice and corruption. They are warned about a third and a fourth time if they revert to the same ways. It then states that this last divine revelation, the Qur’ān, guides to the path that is straightest, while man is often driven by uncontrollable reactions. It also states the rule of individual responsibility with regard to following divine guidance or straying away from it, and collective responsibility with regard to behaviour and practice.

The second part speaks about the truth of God’s oneness, considering it the basis upon which the whole social set up should be built, including the values of work and behaviour. This central issue of faith should be the pivot around which all human life turns.

The third part speaks of pagan superstitions which attribute daughters and partners to God. It also mentions resurrection and how the unbelievers could never imagine it would take place. It shows how they received Qur’ānic revelations and the fabrications they reiterated about the Prophet (peace be upon him). It commands the believers to say something better, unlike the falsehood of unbelievers.

In the fourth part the sūrah explains the reason for not giving the Prophet physical miracles or preternatural phenomena. When such miracles were given to earlier communities and they continued to deny the message of truth, the law God has set in such cases applied to them and they were destroyed. It refers to the unbelievers’ attitude to the warnings based on the vision God showed to the Prophet, and their persistence in their erring ways. In this connection a part of the story of Iblīs, or Satan, is mentioned and his declaration that he would remain for ever man’s determined foe. This part of the story appears to be an exposition of the reasons for the unbelievers going astray. It comments on this by warning mankind against incurring God’s punishment, coupled with a reminder of God’s grace and the honour He has given to mankind. It tells them about what awaits God’s obedient servants, contrasting it with what awaits the disobedient on the day when every community is summoned by calling their leaders or guides. “Those who are given their records in their right hands will read their records. None shall be wronged by as much as a hair’s breadth. But whoever is blind in this world will be even more blind in the life to come, and still further astray from the path of truth.” (Verses 71-72)

The final part of the sūrah speaks about the unbelievers’ schemes against the Prophet (peace be upon him), and their attempts to lure him away from at least part of what was revealed to him. It mentions their attempt to expel him from Makkah.

When he actually left, he did so carrying out God’s orders. Had they forcibly expelled him, they would have been destroyed, as happened to communities which in former times expelled their prophets or killed them. God commands the Prophet in the sūrah to carry on with his mission, reciting the Qur’ān and attending to his prayers, appealing to God to enable him to enter and leave in a true and sincere manner, and to declare that the truth has come to light and falsehood is certain to wither away. The sūrah states that this Qur’ān is a source of cure and guidance to believers. Man’s knowledge, however, remains inadequate. “You, [mankind], have been granted but little knowledge.” (Verse 85)

The sūrah continues to speak about the Qur’ān and its challenge to all mankind.

Yet the unbelievers required physical miracles, and asked for angels to be sent down in support of the Prophet’s message. They suggested that the Prophet should have a house of adornments, or a garden with date and vine trees, through which rivers run, or that he should cause a spring of water to gush forth for them, or that he himself should climb up to heaven and bring them a written letter to read. All these demands were dictated by intransigence, not by the desire to have proof to ensure conviction.

The sūrah replies that all this is beyond the limits of the role of God’s Messenger and the nature of his message. It leaves matters in this regard to God. It derides such demands and those who make them, telling them that had they had control over the treasures of God’s grace, which is always abundant, never exhausted, they would still fear to give it away. It was sufficient for them to realize that everything in the universe glorifies God. They should have remembered that the miracles given to Moses did not lead the ones determined to oppose him to change their minds and follow him. Hence, God inflicted His punishment on them.

The sūrah concludes with a short discourse about the truth inherent in the Qur’ān.

It was revealed in passages, so that the Prophet could read it to people over a long time, as would befit different occasions and circumstances. People would then be influenced by its practical approach to living conditions. It was received by people of sound knowledge with humility. They were so influenced by it to the extent that they wept and prostrated themselves to God. The sūrah then concludes with praising God who has never taken to Himself a son or a partner, just as it began with glorifying Him.

The story of the night journey by the Prophet from the Sacred Mosque in Makkah to the Aqşā Mosque in Jerusalem, and then his ascension from there to the highest heaven and the world of which we know nothing, is mentioned in several reports. It has been the subject of much controversy, which continues even today. There are various reports about the place from which the Prophet’s night journey started. Some suggest that it was the mosque itself, which fits with the phraseology of the verse.

One report quotes the Prophet as saying: “As I was in the mosque, at Ĥijr Ismā`īl, half asleep, Gabriel came to me with al-Burāq...” It is also reported that his journey began from the house of his cousin Umm Hānī. This report is acceptable on the basis that the term, ‘the Sacred Mosque’, includes the whole Ĥaram area, which surrounds the mosque. Ibn `Abbās is reported to have said, “The whole of the Ĥaram area is a mosque.” It is also reported that he was sleeping in Umm Hānī’s house when he was taken on his journey and returned home before the night was over. He related the event to his cousin and told her: “I saw the prophets and led them in prayer.” As he was about to leave to go to the mosque, she stopped him, saying: “I fear that people will not believe you if you tell them what you have just told me.” The Prophet made clear his intention to tell them, ‘even though they would not believe me.’ When the Prophet sat in the mosque, Abū Jahl, the arch-enemy of Islam, went to him and asked him whether he had any news. The Prophet told him of his night journey. Abū Jahl called on people to gather and listen to the strange news the Prophet had to tell them. As the Prophet did so, some of them started clapping as a gesture of rejecting what they heard while others put their hands on their heads in disbelief. Some who had earlier accepted Islam now turned away declaring that they were no longer Muslims. Some went to Abū Bakr, the Prophet’s closest Companion, to find out what his reaction would be. When they assured him that Muĥammad actually claimed to have made the return journey to Jerusalem overnight, Abū Bakr said: “If he has actually said this, he is telling the truth.” When they expressed their amazement that he would believe such a singular story, Abū Bakr said: “What is so surprising? I do believe him when he says something even more incomprehensible.

He says he receives revelations from on high and I believe him.” Abū Bakr was then given the title Şiddīq, which denotes ‘a true and firm believer’.

Some of them had been to Jerusalem and so asked the Prophet to describe it to them. Its picture was raised before his eyes and he described it to them in detail.

They said that his description was accurate. They then asked him to tell them about their trade caravan and when it would arrive. He told them the number of its camels and its condition at the time. He further told them that it would arrive at sunrise on a particular day, headed by a white camel. On the day appointed by the Prophet, they went out to make sure the caravan arrived. When the sun began to rise, they said:

Here is the sun rising. Then they looked and said: And here is the caravan headed by a white camel, just like Muĥammad said. Yet still they refused to believe.

On the same night, the Prophet ascended from Jerusalem to heaven. Disagreement among scholars touches on the point of whether or not the Prophet went on this night journey when he was awake or if it was a dream-like journey. It is reported that `Ā’ishah, his wife, said: “By God, the Prophet’s body was never missing, but it was his soul which ascended.” Al-Ĥasan is reported to have said that it was all in a dream he saw. Other reports make it clear that it was a journey he took, body and soul, and that his bed was still warm when he came back.

The weightier view, on the basis of all the reports we have, is that the Prophet left his bed in his cousin’s home and went to the Ka`bah. When he was at Ĥijr Ismā`īl, half awake, he was taken on his journey to Jerusalem and from there he ascended to heaven, before returning to his bed which was still warm.

Having clarified this, we do not see much point in the long arguments people have engaged in over the past, and still do, concerning the nature of this event which certainly took place. Whether it was a physical or spiritual trip, or a vision he saw while awake or asleep, does not make much difference. It does not alter much of the nature of this event to say that it was an act of unveiling that enabled the Prophet to see remote places and worlds in a brief moment. Those who understand even a little of the nature of God’s power and the nature of prophethood will find nothing strange in this event. To God’s power and ability, all matters, which appear easy or difficult by our human standards and according to what is familiar to us, are the same. What is familiar to us in our world is not to be taken as the criterion for making a judgement in relation to God’s ability. The nature of prophethood is a link with God, which may not be compared to anything familiar in human life. That a remote place or world be shown to the Prophet, or that the Prophet visited such a place by means that we know or do not know about, are no more strange or miraculous than for him to receive God’s message. Indeed Abū Bakr put the matter in its proper perspective when he told the people of Makkah that he believed the Prophet in what was even more incomprehensible: the revelations he received from on high.

The Quraysh had ample hard evidence of the truth of this journey when they asked the Prophet to tell them about their trade caravan, and their subsequent verification of every point of detail he mentioned. But they were bound to meet his story with total disbelief at first. The point to be noted here is that the Prophet did not listen to his cousin, Umm Hānī, when she tried to persuade him not to tell them about his journey for fear of their reaction to what would sound totally impossible.

The Prophet’s trust in the truth of his message and the reality of his journey was such that he went out and told them, paying little heed to how they would receive his news. His mission was to convey to them his message complete, and he was not one to evade his duty. Some of those who had believed in the new faith turned back.

Unbelievers found in his story material for ridicule and doubt about everything he said. But none of this made him hesitate to declare the truth as he saw and believed it. In this the Prophet teaches a lesson to the advocates of Islam across all generations:

they must declare the truth plainly in all situations. They should not fear what reaction this brings about. They must not try to tailor their faith so as to fit in with what people like to hear.

We also note that the Prophet did not try to describe the event as a miracle or a supernatural happening that would make people believe in his message. In fact they were always asking him for a miracle to prove his claims. Now they had the miraculous event and they knew it to be true when they verified the details the Prophet identified. Islam does not rely on miraculous events to present itself to people. Instead it relies only on the nature of its message and its direct appeal to human nature when it is purged of all corrupting influences. When the Prophet spoke out about his journey, he did not seek to make it proof confirming the truth of his message. He only stated a true event, purely and simply because it was true.