Understanding Usul Al-Fiqh by Abu Tariq Hilal - Abu Ismael al-Beirawi

To some, the subject of the role of intellect in Islam seems quite bizarre. Unfortunately, the lack of awareness about Islam yields such an understanding. Through researching the Qur‟an and the life of the Prophet (saw) it is apparent that much emphasis was placed on this subject by the revelation. It is natural for the revelation to address this subject because in order to formulate a specific behaviour, the individual‟s way of thinking must be addressed. When the revelation addressed this crucial issue it did so in such an effective manner that it took only one Ayah for the entire society to abstain from alcohol.

Prophet Muhammad (saw) not only clarified matters of law to the people that dealt with their actions but also directed their intellect and clarified its limitation.

This is evident when the sun eclipsed during the time of the Prophet (saw) on the same day that his (saw) son Ibraheem (ra) died. When people suggested that the sun eclipsed because of the Prophet‟s (saw) son‟s death, he (saw) told them that the sun and the moon are signs from Allah (swt). They do not eclipse for someone‟s death or birth; therefore there is no relationship between the two events.

The method of directing the intellect and sound principles of reason were at work when the Prophet (saw) cleared the misunderstanding of a group of people when they said that rain occurs due to the influence of the star, telling them that the Lord of the star, Allah (swt), causes the rain to occur. These are just two of the many examples addressing the role of the intellect.

Having understood that Islam directed the people‟s intellect, the next question, which arises, is what exactly is the position of the intellect in Islam?

In Islam the role played by the intellect is a very significant one. The intellect is used to understand and accept the Islamic „Aqeedah (doctrine) and is the only acceptable method to enter Islam. Islam compels the use of the intellect to believe in Allah (swt) and forbids imitation (Taqleed) in „Aqeedah.

Islam provides rational evidences to prove the existence and the oneness of Allah (swt), the Prophethood of Muhammad (saw), and that the Qur‟an is the word of Allah (swt). Thus the foundation of Islam is built upon conviction through the intellect. Through this sound proof, the intellect and the heart are satisfied and devoid of any blind faith and superstitions.

Since the authenticity of the Qur‟an and Prophethood of Prophet (saw) is built upon the intellect, the belief in beings such as the angels and Jinns, or descriptions of heaven and hell are based upon the authenticity of the Qur‟an and the Prophethood of Muhammad (saw).

Once the „Aqeedah of Islam is arrived at intellectually, the intellect then plays a different role. It plays a role of only understanding the issue and the revelation and then applying the revelation to the issue. The intellect uses the revelation as a source to derive rulings on any issue, from Wudhu (ablution) to the foreign policy of the Islamic State.

It is important to realise that the intellect cannot be used to conjure up a reason for a ruling, unless the reason is mentioned in the text. Claiming a reason for any ruling implies that we can comprehend what Allah (swt) intended for that ruling, which is impossible. For example, we cannot use the intellect to infer a reason for why we perform Wudhu. The intellect would probably lead one to assume that it is for the sake of personal hygiene.

However, if water is not accessible then we are supposed to do Tayammum (a series of actions requiring one to wipe themselves with dust). If the reasoning behind Wudhu were cleanliness, then why would Allah (swt) order us to wipe ourselves with dust if water is inaccessible?

The proper use of the intellect can be seen in the actions of the Sahabah (ra). During the battle of Badr the Prophet (saw) had stationed the army at a certain location. Habab bin al-Munthir (ra) inquired from the Prophet (saw) whether his (saw)‟s decision was based on the revelation or a tactical decision. The Prophet (saw) replied by saying that it was a tactical decision. Upon this Habab bin al-Munthir said that the location was a wrong one. From this incident we can see that the Sahabah (ra) recognised the fine line between the revelation and the intellect. They never used their thinking to pass judgments on the revelation.

In other ideologies the intellect plays a role that it cannot fulfil. In Western democracies, intellect is given the unlimited role of organising man‟s life; however, it is subject to biases, disparity, differences, contradictions, and the influence of the environment. However, in Islam the intellect is not used to legislate, but to understand the revelation and to apply it.

With regard to the intellect, Muslims need to have the same awareness of the fine line between revelation and „Aql that Habab bin al-Mundthir (ra) had. Unfortunately, Muslims have begun to exercise their intellect to pass on the rulings given to us by Allah (swt), e.g. Salah is good exercise, fasting is good for the body, etc. Furthermore, in some cases Muslims have started to prefer the ruling of man-made laws to those of the Creator of the Universe, Allah (swt).