9.9 Epilogue
Zakah: a new and unique system
I believe the reader realizes by now that zakah is a unique system, unprecedented by any divine or man-made laws. It is a financial, economic, social, political, moral, and religious blend.
It is a well-defined financial tax imposed on heads sometimes, like zakah of al fitr, and other times on capital and income. Thus it represents a permanent and continuous flow of resources to the public treasury of the Islamic state, devoted to liberating men and women from the bondage of need and fulfilling their economic necessities. It fights accumulation of wealth and hoarding it away from circulation and investment It is a social system because zakah secures individuals against disability, accidents, and catastrophes. It realizes humanistic aspirations of social solidarity and cooperation, in which the haves help the have-nots, the strong carry the weak, and the rich give the indigent and wayfarer. The distance shrinks between the rich and the poor, and elements of jealousy, vanity, and hatred are diminished. Moreover, the zakah system financially aids reformers and mediators of disputes to carry on such great missions in order to fulfill the noble social and moral objectives of zakah.
It is political as well, because the institution of zakah is part of the state. The Islamic government takes full responsibility for collecting and distributing zakah according to the principles of justice, and to appoint necessary personal. Additionally, some categories of distribution can only be decided by the state, such as heart reconciliation and, in general, the share spent "in the way of God." It has a moral purpose because the very objective of zakah is to cleanse and purify the souls of the rich from selfishness and desire for accumulation. It aims to train the rich to sacrifice and to contribute to the welfare of other people. Zakah is a sword against jealousy and vanity. It aims at making brotherhood and love prevail among all people in the society.
Before all, it is a religious worship, for performing zakah establishes an essential pillar of Islam. It is one of the basic forms of worship through which men and women obey God and please Him. Additionally, some of its expenditures deal directly with the progress of religion: making Islam know to all people, and reconciling hearts to Islam whether they are hearts of new or prospective converts. The spending of zakah "in the way of God" aims at making the word of God supreme - what a glorious religious objective.
Lastly, zakah alone is bright evidence that this religion is from God, for Muhammad (p), an illiterate man from an illiterate and backward society, could never have thought of such a unique and just system on his own, not with all the information and resources he could muster, if it were not descending from God verse after verse, as a guidance to all human beings, if it were not taught to him by the Most Knowledgeable. Indeed, the bounties of God on Muhammad (p) and on all humanity are magnificent.
Non-Muslim writers give testimony
This unique system of zakah, which is misunderstood and often badly applied by many Muslims, finds admirers among non-Muslims writers who have studied it and given their opinions about it. In his book The Preaching of Islam, Thomas Arnold describes some of the rites of Islam, especially pilgrimage, and then goes on to speak about zakah: "Besides the institution of pilgrimage, we find the performance of zakah another basic obligation which reminds every Muslim of the verse of God, 'Believers are but one brotherhood,' which is a religious ideal realized magnificently in Islamic society in such a way that surprises all of us. It is seen in all acts of tenderness toward fellow Muslims, regardless of race, sex, color, or ancestry. A Muslim becomes a member in the bond of believers and immediately takes his place equal to other Muslims." Lloyd Rouch says, "I find in Islam the solution of the two major social problems that occupy the minds of the world. The first is in the statement of the Qur'an, 'Believers are but one single brotherhood.' This is the most beautiful principle of socialism. The second is the obligation of zakah on every wealthy person and allowing the poor to take it by force if the rich refuse to pay it voluntarily, and this is the cure for anarchy."2
Muhammad Kurd 'Ali quotes another foreign writer as saying about zakah, This tax, in addition to being a religious obligation required from all, is a social system and a source of income for the Muhammadan state which is used to supply and enrich the poor in a systematic, straight forward way, without any arbitrariness or enslavement. It is not a casual event in the life of the Muslim society. This marvelous system was established by Islam for the first time in the history of mankind. This tax, zakah, which is obligated on landlords, merchants, and the wealthy in order to be spent to the indigent, poor and disabled, brought down the barriers that divide the nation into classes, and unifies the Islamic nation into one social group based on justice. By that the Islamic system proves it is not based on hatred or selfishness."3 Muhammad 'Ali quotes also a renown French Orientalist, Massignon, as saying "This religion of Islam has the ability to be strict in realizing the principle of equality, by imposing zakah on every individual, paid to the public treasury and by working against interest loans and indirect taxes that are usually imposed on necessities. At the same time, this religion stands in support of private ownership and commercial capital. Thus Islam stands once more in the middle, balanced between the theories of bourgeoisie capitalism and Bolshevik communism."4
The Italian writer Vagleri says in her book In Defense of Islam "All religions recognize to a certain degree the great moral and social importance of giving charity and encourage it as a material expression of mercy. But Islam alone achieves the glory of making such charity obligatory. Thus transforming the teachings of Christ into ordinances and then reality in the world. Each Muslim is obligated by law to devote certain fraction of his wealth to the poor and needy, wayfarers, and strangers, etc. By performing this religious obligation, believers exercise such deeper humanistic feelings; they purify their souls from selfishness and niggardliness, and hope for divine reward."5
Quotations from Muslim reformists
After quotations from orientalists, we give a few quotations from Muslim writers about zakah. Muhammad Rashid Rida, in his explanation of the Qur'an notes:
In imposing zakah, Islam is distinct from all religions and legislations, as confessed by most writers of many origins. If Muslims would only establish this pillar of their religion, no poor or needy or persons under pressure of debts would ever exist in their societies.
Unfortunately, many Muslims neglect this obligation, and consequently cause harm to their religion and their nation. So they have become the worst of all nations in political and financial matters to the extent that they even lost control of their own countries and became dependent on other nations, even in educating their children. Muslin children today are educated in Christian missionary schools, whereby they are lost to their nations and become enslaved to foreigners. If they are questioned, "why don't you establish schools yourselves on high levels of performance, instead of sending your children to missionary schools?" they answer, 'We do not have financial resources to do so." In reality, they do not have the zeal, the mind and the will to implement their religion. And they see with their own eyes other people spending to finance schools and charitable and political organizations. Thus vow to these Muslims that have lost their religion and thus have indeed lost their worldly living. God says, "Those who forget God, He makes them forget their own souls, such are the rebellious transgressors."6 Those who call for the reform of Muslim societies are required to start by saving the remnants of religion and dignity, by establishing organizations to collect zakah and distribute it according to Shari'ah. They must realize that the share of freeing slaves must be used to liberate people who suffer from colonialism if there is no one in the bondage of slavery, and that the share "in the way of God" must be used to re-establish the Islamic system through the glorious form of jihad, which preserves Islam before the aggression of disbelievers. They must spend to call for Islam and to defend its values by writing and speaking, if such defense is not viable by weapons. We must realize that if all, or the majority of Muslims perform zakah and spend it according to its proper designation, that would be sufficient to re-establish the glory of Islam, to regain what was stolen from Muslim land by foreigners, and to salvage Muslims from enslavement to unbelievers. This can be done only by spending one-tenth or one-quarter of a tenth from the wealth owned by the rich. We observe with our own eyes that may people who dominate over Muslim lands spend more than that for their own nations and ideologies, without even being obligated by their Lord.7
In his comment on the saying from Mu'adh that the Prophet (p) told him "Inform them that God imposes on them in their wealth a sadaqah, to be taken from the rich among them and rendered to the poor among them." Shaikh Mahmud Shaltut, former head of al Azhar mosque, says, These Prophet's instructions indicate that zakah in Islam is simply a transfer of the excess wealth of the nation within itself, since it is taken from the rich and given to the poor. In other words, zakah only changes control of some fraction of wealth from one hand-- the hand that invests and protect -- to the other hand - the hand that works and struggle (when the yield of that work is not sufficient for all their needs), or to the hand that cannot work, which is the hand of the poor.8
Footnotes.
1. The Preaching of Islam, by Thomas Arnold, translated by Dr. Hasan Ibrahim Hasan and his colleague, p. 167.
2. Islam and Arabic culture, by Muhammad Kurd 'Ali.
3. Ibid, pp. 76-77.
4. Ibid.
5. In Defense of Islam, p. 69.
6. Sura al Hashr, 59:19.
7. Tafsir al Manar, Vol. 2.
8. Al Islam, 'Aqidah wa Shari'ah, by Mahmud Shaltut.
9. Sura al Tawbah, 9:103.
10. Ibid, 9:60.
11. Usus al Iqtisad fi al Islam, by Abu al A'la al Maududi, p. 28-131.
12. See al kharaj, by Abu Yusuf, especially the introduction by Burhan Sati'.
13. Al Arkan al Arba'ah, by Abu al Hasan al Nadwi, pp.120-122.