使其与英语读者相关
Making It Relevant To English Speakers
这种对文学和语言特征的分析与阿拉伯语中的"平辞学"(balāgha,بالغة)相关。它涵盖修辞手法的运用,即旨在取悦和说服听众的语言;辞藻之美,包括用词的选择、语序和简洁性;以及文体、结构与意义之间的相互关联。说英语的人或许熟悉这些概念,但鉴于本文的语境,所呈现内容的相关性也许值得商榷。
The analysis of literary and linguistic features is related to balāgha (بالغة (in the Arabic language.2 This encompasses the use of rhetorical devices, which refers to language that aims to please and persuade; eloquence, including choice of words, word order and conciseness; and the interrelation between style, structure and meaning. English speakers may be familiar with these ideas, however given the context of this essay, the relevance of the content presented may be questioned.
需要指出的是,这些文学和语言特征是普遍存在的,并不仅限于阿拉伯语。例如,在英语中,我们运用大量修辞手法来表达思想,使其不仅仅是冷冰冰、机械地传递信息。马克·福赛斯(Mark Forsyth)在其著作《雄辩的要素:完美措辞的秘诀》(The Elements of Eloquence: Secrets of the Perfect Turn of Phrase)中列举了三十多种修辞手法,或称修辞格,旨在达到上述效果。例如,他提到一种称为“首尾重复”(diacope)的修辞手法。这种表达采用 A B A 的形式,正因如此,它在某种程度上使陈述更有力量、更易记住。“Bond, James Bond”(邦德,詹姆斯·邦德)就是一个首尾重复的例子。詹姆斯·邦德本可以用多种不同的方式介绍自己的名字,但他以首尾重复的形式呈现,给听者造成一种效果,使这句话令人难忘。4
It is important to note that these literary and linguistic features are universal and not only applicable to the Arabic language.3 For instance, in the English language, we use numerous rhetorical devices to convey ideas in a manner that transcends the mere cold, clinical transfer of information. Mark Forsyth in his book, The Elements of Eloquence: Secrets of the Perfect Turn of Phrase, lists over thirty five rhetorical devices, or figures of rhetoric, that aim to achieve the above. For example, he mentions a rhetorical device referred to as ‘diacope’. This is a statement in the form A B A, and because the statement is in this form, it somehow makes the statement more powerful and memorable. “Bond, James Bond” is an example of a diacope. Mr. James Bond could have stated his name in a number of different ways but by presenting it in the form of a diacope, he delivers an effect on the listener that causes the statement to be memorable.4
修辞之美的概念在思考诗歌与散文的区别时得以凸显。诗歌与散文都传达思想。然而,一首好诗会吸引读者反复品读,去欣赏其表达中动人的美感;而散文则以最有效的方式传递信息,读者未必会有重读的冲动。以艾米莉·狄金森的诗歌《希望是长着羽毛的东西》为例:
The conceptualisation of eloquence is highlighted when one thinks about the difference between poetry and prose. Both poetry and prose convey ideas. However, a good poem invites the reader to revisit the poem and enjoy the persuasive beauty of its expression, while prose would deliver information in the most effective way possible and the reader may not feel the urge to revisit it. Consider, for example, Emily Dickinson’s poem Hope is the Thing with Feathers:
“希望”是长着羽毛的东西——
“Hope” is the thing with feathers –.
栖息在灵魂之中——
That perches in the soul –.
并且只哼唱曲调而不唱歌词——
And sings the tune without the words –.
而且从不停止——丝毫不停。
And never stops – at all –.
最甜美的,在狂风中,听得见——。
And sweetest – in the Gale – is heard –.
而暴风雨必定猛烈——。
And sore must be the storm –.
那可能会让这只小鸟感到羞愧。
That could abash the little Bird.
那些温暖的时光……一直陪伴着许多人。
That kept so many warm –.
我在最平静的土地上听到了它——
I’ve heard it in the chillest land –.
而在那最奇异的海上——
And on the strangest Sea –.
然而——绝不——在极端的情况下。
Yet – never – in Extremity,.
它问我要一点点东西——问我要了一点。5。
It asked a crumb – of me.5.
如果将一本有机化学教科书与上面的那首诗作一番比较,便会发现:对于诗歌而言,风格至关重要。我们从阅读诗歌本身就能获得愉悦,而教科书最重要的品质则在于传达技术性信息。《古兰经》的独特之处之一,正是它以一种语义上最为妥当的方式高效地传递信息,这正是我们对散文所期待的;同时,它又让读者体验到一种动人而有说服力的美感,这正是我们对诗歌所期待的。撇开进一步的技术细节和其他微妙之处,这已足以作为本文的引言,引出接下来将要展开和阐释的那些普遍性观点。
If a comparison were to be made between a textbook on organic chemistry and the poem above, we can see that in the case of the poem the style is of utmost importance. We are deriving pleasure from the mere reading of the poem while the most important quality of the textbook is the conveying of technical information. One of the unique features of the Qur’ān is its efficient transfer of information in a semantically optimal way, as we would expect from prose, all the while presenting the reader with the pleasant experience of persuasive beauty, as we would expect from a poem. Notwithstanding further technicalities, and other nuances, this suffices as an introduction to the universality of the ideas that are going to be unpacked and explained in this essay.