“Lakini wakirejea katika utii, basi msiwatafutie njia ya kuwaudhi.” [An-Nisa: 34] Badala yake, awe rafiki kwake, na awe mwema anapomwomba jambo, kiasi kwamba akitaka kumkaribia, achague wakati na hali iliyo bora na inayomfaa. Alisema ﷺ: “Msiwakaribie wake zenu usiku hadi yule mwenye nywele zilizochafuka azichanue, na yule ambaye mumewe amekuwa mbali aisafishe sehemu zake za siri (za nywele).”
Utawala wa mume juu ya mke na uongozi wake wa nyumba hauna maana ya kuwa mtawala wa kiburi ndani yake au kuwa mwenye mamlaka ya kutoruhusu kupingwa kwa jambo lolote. Bali uongozi wa mume juu ya nyumba ni kusimamia mambo yake na kuiendesha, wala hakuna utawala wala amri za kulazimisha ndani yake. Kwa hiyo, mwanamke ana haki ya kumjibu mumewe na kujadiliana naye na kukosoa anachosema, kwa sababu wao ni washirika na si mwenye amri na mwenye kuamriwa, wala mtawala na anayetawaliwa. Badala yake, ni washirika wawili, mmoja wao akiwa na uongozi katika kuendesha nyumba na kusimamia mambo yake. Katika nyumba yake, Mtume wa Allah ﷺ vivyo hivyo alikuwa mshirika kwa wake zake, si mtawala mwenye kiburi juu yao, licha ya kuwa kiongozi wa dola na licha ya kuwa Nabii.
Umar bin al-Khattab alisema katika Hadith aliyoipokea: “Kwa Allah, wakati wa zama za Ujinga tulikuwa tukiwapuuza wanawake, hadi Allah Mtukufu alipoteremsha kuhusu wao yale aliyoteremsha, na akawapa sehemu yao.” Akasema: “Ikawa nilikuwa nikiwaza jambo fulani, mke wangu akasema: ‘Ningependa ungefanya hivi na hivi.’ Nikamwambia: ‘Halikuhusu, wala usijiingize katika kile ninachokusudia kufanya.’ Akaniambia: ‘Ni ajabu jinsi gani wewe, mwana wa Khattab, usivyopenda mtu yeyote akujibu, ilhali binti yako anamjibu Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ hadi anatumia siku nzima akiwa na huzuni.’” Umar alisema: "Nilichukua vazi langu, kisha nikatoka nyumbani mwangu hadi nilipomtembelea Hafsa, nikamwambia: 'Ee binti yangu, (nimesikia) kwamba unamjibu Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ kiasi kwamba anatumia siku nzima katika karaha.'" Hafsa akasema: "Wallahi, sisi tunamjibu." Nikasema: "Jihadhari, binti yangu, ninakuonya dhidi ya adhabu ya Allah na ghadhabu ya Mjumbe wake ﷺ. Usidanganywe na yule ambaye uzuri wake, na mapenzi ya Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ kwake, vimemvutia" (maana yake ni Aisha). Kisha mimi (Umar) nilimtembelea Umm Salama kwa sababu ya uhusiano wangu naye, nikazungumza naye. Umm Salama akaniambia: "Umar bin al-Khattab, ni jambo la ajabu jinsi unavyojiingiza katika kila jambo hadi unakusudia kujiingiza kati ya Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ na wake zake." Hili lilinikasirisha sana hadi nikaacha kusema nilichokuwa nimekusudia, kisha nikatoka katika chumba chake."
Muslim anasimulia katika Sahih yake kwamba Abu Bakr alikuja akaomba ruhusa ya kumwona Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ. Ruhusa ikatolewa kwa Abu Bakr, akaingia. Kisha akaja Umar, akaomba ruhusa, naye akapewa ruhusa, akamkuta Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ ameketi, mwenye huzuni na kimya, na wake zake wamemzunguka. Akasema: "Nilitaka kusema jambo ambalo lingemfanya Nabii Mtukufu ﷺ acheke, kwa hiyo nikasema: 'Ee Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ, laiti ungemwona binti wa Kharijah aliponiomba matumizi (nafaqah), nikasimama na kumpiga kofi shingoni.'" Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ akacheka, akasema: "Wao wamenizunguka kama unavyoona, wakiomba matumizi (nafaqah)."
Kutokana na hili inadhihirika kwamba maana ya utawala wa mwanaume juu ya mwanamke ni kwamba amri iwe mikononi mwake, lakini iwe amri inayotokana na urafiki na si utawala na udhibiti. Hivyo, mwanamke anaweza kumjibu na kujadiliana naye.
“But if they return to obedience, seek not against them means (of annoyance)”. [An- Nisa: 34] Rather He should be a friend to her, and kind when He requests something of her, to the extent if He desires her He should choose the best situation and condition suitable for her. He (pbuh) said: “Do not approach wives at night until the one with dishevelled hair has it combed and the one whose husband has been away has cleaned her private parts (of hair).” Guardianship of the husband over the wife and his leadership of the house does not mean being domineering in it or being its ruler such that no issue is opposed. Rather the leadership of the husband over the house is the looking after its affairs and administering it and there is no domination or commanding in it. Therefore, the woman has the right to answer back to her husband and debate with Him and criticise what He says because they are companions and not a commander and commanded, or a ruler and a ruled. On the contrary they are two companions, one of whom possesses leadership in terms of running the house and looking after its affairs. In his house, the Messenger of Allah , was likewise a companion to his wives, not a domineering ruler over them, in spite of his being the leader of a state and in spite of being a Prophet. 'Umar b. al-Khattab said in a Hadith reported by Him: “By Allah, during the days of Ignorance we ignored women until Allah the Exalted revealed about them what He has revealed, and gave them a share.” He said: “It so happened that I was thinking about some matter when my wife said: 'I wish that you had done so and so'. I said to her: “It does not concern you, and you should not interfere in what I intend to do.” She said to me: 'How strange is it that you, son of Khattab, do not like anyone to answer you back, whereas your daughter answers back Allah's Messenger (pbuh) until He spends the day in vexation'. Umar said: “I took hold of my cloak, then came out of my house until I visited Hafsa and said to her: Oh daughter, (I heard) that you answer back to Allah's Messenger (pbuh) until He spends the day in vexation.” Hafsa said: 'By Allah, we do answer Him back'. I said: “Be careful, my daughter, I warn you against the punishment of Allah and the wrath of his Messenger (pbuh). You may not be misled by the one whose beauty, and the love of Allah's Messenger (pbuh) for her have fascinated her(meaning A'isha). I ('Umar) then visited Umm Salama because of my relationship with her and I talked to her. Umm Salama said to me: 'Umar b. al-Khattab, how strange it is that you interfere in every matter to the extent that you intend to interfere between Allah's Messenger (pbuh) and his wives'. This perturbed me so much that I refrained from saying what I had to say, so I came out of her apartment.”. Muslim narrates in his Sahih that Abu Bakr came and sought permission to see Allah's Messenger (pbuh). It was granted to Abu Bakr and He entered. Then came Umar and He sought permission and it was granted to Him and He found Allah's Messenger (pbuh) sitting sad and silent with his wives around Him. He (Umar) said: “I wanted to say something which would make the Holy Prophet (pbuh) laugh, so I said: ‘Oh Messenger of Allah, I wish you had seen the daughter of Kharijah when she asked me for maintenance (Nafaqah), and I got up and slapped her on her neck.’ The Messenger of Allah (pbuh) laughed and said: “They are around me as you see, asking for maintenance (Nafaqah)” From this it becomes clear that the meaning of the man's guardianship over the woman is that the command should rest with Him, but it should be a command borne out of companionship and not domination and control. Thus she can answer back to Him and discuss with Him.