Quran Course
All BooksDownloads
All BooksDownloadsSystem Of Islam
Also visitSystem Of Islam
Built with love by StudioToronto.ca
Quran Course
All BooksDownloads
All BooksDownloadsSystem Of Islam
0%
The Islamic Personality8 min readViewed 3 times

10.1 Tafsīr (qur’ānic Exegesis)


The word tafsīr is the form taf'eel from the word al-fasr which means to explain (bayan). You say I explained the thing (without pronouncing the tashdeed), 'afsuruhu fasran', and I explained it (with the tashdeed); 'ufassiruhu tafsīran' when you explained it. The difference between tafsīr and ta'weel is that tafsīr is the explanation of what is intended by the wording and ta'weel is the explanation of what is intended by the meaning. The word tafsīr is chosen when applying to the explanation of the verses of the Qur’ān. The Qur’ān has been revealed in the Arabic language so its expressions are Arabic, including the expressions which are of a foreign origin like istabraq (brocade). It is has been Arabized according to the principles of Arabic and it became part of the Arabic expressions. The style of the Qur’ān is the well-known way of Arabs in their speech. He  said:

“An Arabic Qur’ān” [TMQ Zumar: 28]

The Arabs used to recite it, comprehend the strength of its eloquence and understand its meanings. But not all of the Qur’ān can be approached by all Arabs who would understand it generally and specifically just by merely listening to it because by revealing the Qur’ān in the language of the Arabs does not mean that all Arabs will understand its words and phrases. Since not every book written in a certain language can be understood by the people of that language. The understanding of a book does not require language only but also a level of intellect in understanding and comprehension which agrees with the level and elevation of the book. The reality of the Arabs when the Qur’ān was being revealed was that not all of them were able to understand the Qur’ān generally and specifically. Rather, they used to differ in their understanding according to their intellectual elevation. Because of that reason the Sahabah's ability to explain and understand the Qur’ān was at variance due to the disparity of their understanding of the Arabic language and also due to the disparity in their intelligence and comprehension. The Qur’ānic expressions themselves and their meanings were not all understood by all Arabs. Anas ibn Malik narrated that a man asked 'Umar ibn al-Khattab about His  saying:

“And fruits and abba (herbage, etc)” [TMQ ‘Abasa: 31]

What is the abba? 'Umar replied:

‘We have been forbidden from over-burdening ourselves and going excessively deep into issues’

It has also been narrated about 'Umar that he was on the minbar and he read:

“Or that He that he may catch them with takhawwuf (gradual wasting of their and health)” [TMQ Nahl: 47]

Then he inquired about the meaning of takhawwuf? A man from Huzayl said: takhawwuf for us is the gradual decrease (tanaqqus).

Furthermore, there are many verses in the Qur’ān for whose understanding knowledge of linguistic expressions and styles is not sufficient. Rather, they require information about certain expressions because these expressions point to specific meanings such as in His  saying:

“By (the winds) that scatter dust” [TMQ Dhāriyāt: 1]

“By the (steeds) that run, with panting (breath)” [TMQ ‘aadiyaat: 1]

“Verily ! We have sent it (this Qur’ān) down in the night of al-qadr (decree)” [TMQ Qadr: 1]

“By the dawn ; by the ten nights ( that is, the first ten days of the month of Dhul-hijja)” [TMQ Fajr: 1-2]

And other such verses which point to well known meanings, there are other verses whose understanding requires knowledge of the causes of revelation.

There are verses in the Qur’ān which are muhkam (explicit) and clear in meaning. They are the verses especially the Makkan verses which pertain to the fundamentals of the deen in terms of the ‘aqīdah and the verses which pertain to the fundamentals of the rules which are the Madinan verses, especially those related to transactions (mu'amalat), punishments ('uqubat) and testimonies (bayyinat). There are mutashabihat (ambiguous) verses as well in the Qur’ān which are ambiguous in meaning for many people, especially the verses that are open to a number of meanings or necessitates leaving the apparent meaning for another meaning because of the contradiction with the creed which should be free of anthropomorphic elements.

Even though the Sahabah were the most competent in understanding the Qur’ān because they were the most knowledgeable in the Arabic language and because they witnessed the circumstances and events around which the Qur’ān was revealed. However, they differed in their understanding and they differed in their ability to explain (tafsīr) the Qur’ān due to the disparity in the level of their familiarity with the Arabic language and due to the disparity in their closeness to the Messenger . The most famous Mufassirun from the Sahabah were 'Ali ibn Abi Talib, 'Abd Allah ibn 'Abbas, 'Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud and Ubay ibn Ka'b, they are the four who nurtured the most amount of exegetical material to the different Muslim cities. What enabled them to have such a deep knowledge of tafsīr was their strong understanding of the Arabic language, their grasp of its rhetorical form and styles, their mixing with the Prophet  and being close to him which enabled them to know the events for which verses of the Qur’ān were revealed and their faculty of intellect and intelligence, a faculty which enabled them to link meanings together in the best manner and come out with correct results. That is why they did not refrain from making Ijtihād in understanding the Qur’ān according to what the mind demanded. Rather, they made Ijtihād in tafsīr and spoke about it within their own opinions (Ijtihāds) and they made decisions based on what they had arrived at by their understanding and Ijtihād. Therefore, the tafsīrs of those people are considered as one of the highest forms of tafsīr. But many have lied about them and sayings have been interpolated in their tafsīr which they did not say, that is why you will find many fabrications in their tafsīr. What has been authenticated by trustworthy narrators is the strongest of tafsīrs. As for everything else from the fabricated reports it is not permitted to take them since it has not been proven that they said them. However, the caution of taking fabricated tafsīrs of those four does not mean it is a caution for reading their tafsīrs. Rather, it is a caution against taking them and practising them given the consideration that these are fabrications. As for reading them and determining a correct understanding by the language, Sharī’ah and intellect with what has been mentioned in them, this is useful because there are valuable explanations (tafsīrs) in these fabricated reports in terms of understanding even though their chains of transmission are weak in terms of their ascription to the Sahabah.

← Previous chapterNext chapter →
Chapters (185)
  1. 1Transliteration Guide
  2. 21. Personality
  3. 31.1 The Islamic Personality
  4. 41.2 The Formation Of Personality
  5. 51.3 Gaps In Conduct
  6. 62. The Islamic Aqidah
  7. 72.1 The Meaning Of Imān In The Day Of Resurrection
  8. 82.2 The Emergence Of The Mutakallimīn And Their Approach
  9. 92.3 The Error In The Methodology Of The Mutakallimīn
  10. 102.4 How The Issue Of Al-qadaa’ Wa‘l- Qadar Emerged
  11. 112.5 Al-qadr
  12. 122.6 Al-qadā’
  13. 132.7 Al-qadā’ Wa‘l-qadar
  14. 142.8 Guidance And Misguidance
  15. 152.9 The Termination Of The Life-span [ajāl ] Is The Sole Cause Of Death
  16. 162.10 Provision [rizq] Is In The Hands Of Allah Alone
  17. 172.11 The Attributes [sifāt] Of Allah
  18. 182.12 The Muslim Philosophers
  19. 192.13 The Prophets And Messengers
  20. 202.14 The Infallibility Of The Prophets
  21. 212.15 The Revelation
  22. 222.16 It Is Not Allowed On The Part Of The Messenger Pbuh That He Be A Mujtahid
  23. 233. The Noble Qur'ān
  24. 243.1 The Compilation Of The Qur’ān
  25. 253.2 The Qur’ānic Script
  26. 263.3 The Miracle Of The Qur’ān
  27. 274. The Sunnah
  28. 284.1 The Sunnah Is A Sharī’ah Evidence Like The Qur’ān
  29. 294.2 Inferring Evidences From The Sunnah
  30. 304.3 The Solitary Report (khabar Al-ahad) Is Not A Decisive Proof (hujjah) For Beliefs
  31. 314.4 The Difference Between The ‘aqīdah And The Sharī’ah Rule (hukm Shar’i)
  32. 325. Ijtihād And Taqlīd
  33. 335.1 Expert Research (ijtihād)
  34. 345.2 The Conditions Of Ijtihād
  35. 355.2 Taqlīd
  36. 365.3 The Reality Of Taqlīd
  37. 375.4 The States Of Muqallidin And Their Preponderant Qualifications
  38. 385.5 Migrating From One Mujtahid To Another
  39. 396. Learning The Sharī’ah Rule
  40. 407. The Strength Of The Evidence (quwwa Al-dalīl)
  41. 418. Consultation (shūrā) Or The Adoption Of An Opinion In Islam
  42. 429. Science And Culture
  43. 439.1 The Islamic Culture
  44. 449.2 The Method Of Study In Islam
  45. 459.3 Acquisition Of Culture (thaqafa) And Sciences
  46. 469.4 The Cultural Movement
  47. 479.5 The Position Of Muslims With Regards To Non- Muslim Cultures
  48. 4810. The Islamic Disciplines
  49. 4910.1 Tafsīr (qur’ānic Exegesis)
  50. 5010.2 The Exegetical Approaches Of Mufassirun
  51. 5111. Sources Of Tafsīr
  52. 5211.1 The Ummah's Need Today For Mufassirin
  53. 5312. The Science Of Ḥadīth (‘ilm Al-ḥadīth)
  54. 5412.1 The Hadīth
  55. 5512.2 The Transmitters Of Hadīth (ruwat Al Hadith)
  56. 5612.3 The One Whose Narration Is Accepted And The One Whose Narration Is Not Accepted And The Exposition Of (the Science Of) Invalidation And Attestation Of Reliability (al-jarh Wa Ta'dīl)
  57. 5712.4 Narrations Of The Muslim Sects
  58. 5812.5 Arration By Meaning (riwaya Bil Ma’na) And Abridgement Of The Hadīth
  59. 5912.6 Categories Of Hadīth
  60. 6012.7 Categories Of The Khabar Al-ahād
  61. 6112.8 The Accepted Hadīth (maqbul) And The Rejected Hadīth (mardud)
  62. 6212.9 The Mursal Hadīth
  63. 6312.10 The Ḥadīth Qudsi
  64. 6412.11 The Inability To Prove The Authenticity Of A Hadīth From Its Sanad Does Not Indicate That It Is A Weak Hadīth
  65. 6512.12 Consideration Of The Hadīth As An Evidence In The Sharī’ah Rules
  66. 6613. Prophetic Biography (sīrah) And History
  67. 6714. The Principles Of Islamic Jurisprudence (usūl Al-fiqh)
  68. 6814.1 Fiqh (jurisprudence)
  69. 6914.2 The Development Of Fiqh
  70. 7014.3 The Effect Of Disputes And Debates (munazarat) On Islamic Jurisprudence
  71. 7114.4 The Flourishing Of Islamic Jurisprudence
  72. 7214.5 The Decline Of Islamic Jurisprudence
  73. 7314.6 The Myth Of The Influence Of Roman Law On Islamic Jurisprudence
  74. 7415. Studying Fiqh
  75. 7516. Examples (namadhij) Of Fiqh
  76. 7617. The Khilafah
  77. 7717.1 The Time Limit Given For Muslims To Appoint A Khalifah
  78. 7817.2 Contracting (in’iqad) The Khilafah
  79. 7917.3 The Pledge (bay’ah)
  80. 8017.4 The Conditions Of Eligibility For The Khalifah
  81. 8117.5 Seeking The Khilafah Post
  82. 8217.6 The Unity Of The Khilafah
  83. 8317.7 Succession (istikhlaf) Or Reign (‘ahd)
  84. 8417.8 The Method To Appoint The Khalifah
  85. 8517.9 The Shar'a Did Not Designate A Specific Person For The Khilafah
  86. 8617.10 General Responsibilities/duties
  87. 8718 The Islamic State Is A Human State And Not A Theocratic State.
  88. 8818.1 Deposing Or Removal Of The Khalifah
  89. 8919. The Leadership (al-imarah)
  90. 9019.1 Obedience (at-ta’ah)
  91. 9119.2 The Khalifah's Adoption Of Rules And Styles I.e. Adopting Canons
  92. 9220. Jihad
  93. 9320.1 The Khalifah And Jihad
  94. 9420.2 The Meaning Of The Khalifah Supervising The Army's Leadership
  95. 9520.3 The Martyr
  96. 9620.4 Guarding The Frontiers (ar-ribat)
  97. 9720.5 The Islamic Army
  98. 9820.6 Seeking The Assistance Of Disbelievers In Fighting
  99. 9920.7 Preparing The Islamic Army
  100. 10020.8 Flags And Banners
  101. 10120.9 Captives
  102. 10221. The War Policy
  103. 10321.1 Lying In War
  104. 10421.2 Spying
  105. 10521.3 Truce (hudna)
  106. 10621.4 Military Alliances
  107. 10721.5 Permissible Treaties
  108. 10821.6 Emergency Treaties
  109. 10921.7 Annulling Treaties
  110. 11021.8the Belligerent Disbeliever (kafir Harbi)
  111. 11121.9 The Protected Person (al-m'ustamin)
  112. 11221.10 The Rules Of The Dhimmi
  113. 11322. Implementing Islam Is Obligatory Upon The Disbelievers
  114. 11423. The Jizyah
  115. 11524. The Lands Of Ushr, Kharaj And Sulh (truce)
  116. 11625. Dar Al-kufr And Dar Al-islam
  117. 11726. The Believer's Befriending The Disbelievers
  118. 11826.1 The Emigration (hijrah) From Dar Al-kufr To Dar Al-islam
  119. 11927. The Position Of Islam On Slaves And Slavery
  120. 12027.1 Treating Slaves
  121. 12127.2 Treating Slavery
  122. 12228. Relationships Between Individuals
  123. 12329. Trade (bai’)
  124. 12429.1 Everything Forbidden For Man, Trading It Is Also Forbidden
  125. 12529.2 It Is Not Allowed To Sell What You Do Not Have
  126. 12629.3 The Selling Of Advance Credit (as-salam)
  127. 12729.4 Buying Fruits While They Are Still On The Tree
  128. 12829.5 Sale On Credit And Instalments (taqseet)
  129. 12929.6 Brokerage (samsara)
  130. 13030. Hiring
  131. 13130.1 The Employee
  132. 13230.2 The Wage
  133. 13330.3 Estimating The Wage
  134. 13430.4 The Amount Of The Wage
  135. 13530.5 Paying The Wage
  136. 13630.6 Types Of Employees
  137. 13730.7 There Is No Labour Problem In Islam
  138. 13830.7 Hiring Assets
  139. 13930.8 Renting Houses For Residence
  140. 14031. All Bribery Is Forbidden
  141. 14132. Mortgage/ Pledging Security
  142. 14232.1 The Pledgee Benefiting From The Pledge
  143. 14333. The Bankrupt
  144. 14434. Transfer Of A Right (al-hawala)
  145. 14535. Drawing & Painting
  146. 14636. Usul Al-fiqh
  147. 14736.1 Al-hākim
  148. 14836.2 There is no hukm Prior to the coming of the revelation
  149. 14936.3 The legally responsible with respect to the shari’ah rulings
  150. 15037. The conditions of legal responsibility [shurūt al-taklīf]
  151. 15137.1 The legal ruling [al-hukm al-shar’i]
  152. 15237.2 The address of legal responsibility [khitab al-taklīf]
  153. 15337.3 The obligatory [al-wajib]
  154. 15437.4 That which is required to fulfill a wājib is itself wājib
  155. 15537.5 The prohibition [al-harām]
  156. 15637.6 The permissible [al-mubāh]
  157. 15737.7 The declaratory address [khitāb al-wad’]
  158. 15938. The Cause ( Al Sabab)
  159. 16039. The Condition ( Al Shart)
  160. 16140. The Prohibitive ( Al Manay)
  161. 16241. The Validity, The Invalidity, And The Corruption ( Al Sihhah, Wal Butlan, Wal Fasaad)
  162. 16342. The Determination And The Consession ( Al Azeema War Rukhsah)
  163. 16443. The Shari'ah Evidences ( Al Adilla-tul- Shariyah )
  164. 16544. The Shariah Evidences Must Be Decisives ( Al Adillah- Tu-shariah Yajebo An Takoona Qateyyah)
  165. 166What Is Considered As A Proof (hujjah) Of The Qur’aan
  166. 167Al-muhkam Wa Al-mutashabih The Precise And The Imprecise
  167. 168The Second Daleel Al–sunnah
  168. 16948. The Status Of The Sunnah In Relation To The Qur'aan
  169. 17049. Divisions Of The Sunnah (aqsaam Al Sunnah)
  170. 17150. The Mutawaatir
  171. 17251. The Number By Which The Certainty Occurs
  172. 17352. The Famous Hadeeth (al Mashhour)
  173. 17453. The Individuals Report (khabar Al Aahaad)
  174. 17554. The Narrators Of The Hadeeth (ruwaat Al Hadeeth)
  175. 17655. Types Of The Individuals Report
  176. 17756. Conditions For Accepting The Individuals Report
  177. 17857. The Actions Of The Messenger
  178. 17958. The Ways By Which The Direction (quality) Of The Action Of The Messenger Can Be Known
  179. 18059. The Silence Of The Prophet (saw)
  180. 18160. The Conflict Between The Actions Of The Messenger (saw)
  181. 18261. The Conflict Between The Action Of The Messenger (saw) And His Saying
  182. 18362. The Conflict Between The Sayings Of The Messenger (saw)
  183. 18463. The Inference (al Istidlaal) From The Kitaab And The Sunnah
  184. 18564. The Language Discussions
  185. 18665. The Way To Know The Arabic Language

After the Sahabah came the Tibi'un. Some of them became famous for transmitting from the Sahabah, from the four mentioned above and from others. The most famous from those Tabi'un are Mujahid, 'Ata ibn Abi Rabah, 'Ikrama freedman of Ibn 'Abbas and Sa'id ibn Jubayr. The 'Ulama have differed on the degree of trust put on those Mufassirun from the Tabi'un, so Mujahid is the most reliable even though he had the fewest narrations and some imams and muhaddithun like Shafi'i and Bukhari rely on his tafsīr. However, some of them observed that Mujahid used to ask the People of the Book. So from this perspective they would give his sayings thorough consideration before taking them though they agreed on his honesty. Both 'Ata and Sa'id were trustworthy and honest and no one has questioned their honesty. As for 'Ikrama, most scholars trust him and believe him. And Bukhari transmits from him but others view him as taking risks in tafsīr thinking that he knows everything about the Qur’ān. And that was due to the huge amount of Qur’ānic tafsīr he has narrated from the Sahabah. From the four, 'Ikrama was the one who transmitted mostly from Ibn 'Abbas. There are those who used to narrate from rest of the Sahabah like Masruq ibn al-Ajda', the student of 'Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud, he used to narrate tafsīr from him. From the Tabi'un, Qatada ibn Da'ama Assudoos AlAkma also became well known for tafsīr. He had an extensive knowledge of the Arabic language and was well versed in Arabic poetry, the era of the Arabs and their genealogy. After the end of the era of the Tabi'un, the 'Ulama began to compile books of tafsīr following a specific method, which is to mention the verse and then quote what has been reported from the tafsīrs of the Sahabah and the Tabi'un along with their chains. Some of them who were famous for this method were Sufyan ibn 'Uyayna, Waki' ibn al-Jarrah, 'Abd al-Razzaq and others.Though the tafsīrs of these people have not reached us in their entirety rather what has reached us are statements found in some of the books of tafsīr like the tafsīr of al-Tabari. Then after them came al-Farra' and then came al Tabari. Then scholars of tafsīr came one after another in every age until our time.