11.4 Muqallid ning bir fikrdan boshqasiga o‘tishi
11.4 Muqalid shifting from one Opinion to Another
Ba'zan odamga ikki mujtahidning ijtihodidan kelib chiqqan ikki hukm o'rtasida tanlov qilish mumkin bo'lib tuyuladi. Masalan, xotinga qo'l urish vuzuni buzadimi? Imom Shofe'iy: ha, buzadi, deydi. Imom Abu Hanifa: yo'q, buzmaydi, deydi.
Sometimes it occurs to a person that he can choose between two rules derived from the Ijtihad of two Mujtahideen. For example, does touching one‟s wife break the Wudhu? Imam Shafi‟i says yes. Imam Abu Hanifah says no.
Ikkala fikr ham dalilga asoslangan. Ba'zilar aytadiki, Islom osondir, shuning uchun eng osonini tanlash kerak. Axir ikkalasi ham islomiy fikrlardir. Bir fikrga o'z xohishi sababli ergashish butunlay haromdir (taqiqlangan). Chunki islomiy fikrga ergashish Hukmi shar'iyga ergashishni anglatadi. Hukmi shar'iyga itoat qilish qiyinchilikka, osonlikka yoki manfaatga asoslanmaydi. Unda muqallid ikki islomiy fikr orasida qanday tanlaydi?
Both opinions are based on the Daleel. Some say that Islam is easy therefore choose the easiest. After all both are Islamic opinions. To follow one of the opinions because of one‟s desires is totally Haram (forbidden). As following an Islamic opinion means following the Hukm Shar‟i. The obedience to Hukm Shar‟i is not based on hardship, easiness or benefit. How then does a Muqallid choose between two Islamic opinions?