4.8 Mbinu na Mtindo
4.8 The Method And Style
Swali linalojitokeza sasa ni kama yale aliyosema au kufanya Mtume ﷺ wakati wa maisha yake huko Makka yanachukuliwa kuwa ni wahyi kutoka kwa Allah (SWT), na kwa hiyo ni wajibu kuyafuata. Au kuna vitendo na kauli ambazo si za wahyi na haziko ndani ya eneo ambalo mtu anawajibika kuiga?
The question that arises now is whether what the Messenger said or did during his life in Makkah is considered a revelation from Allah , and consequently it is an obligation to adhere to it. Or are there actions and sayings which are not from the revelation and do not come under the area that one is obliged to emulate?
Ni kutokana na mtazamo huu ndipo mjadala kuhusu mbinu, njia na mtindo unapojitokeza.
It is from this angle that the discussion on method, means and style arises.
Swali jingine pia linazuka: je, ni sahihi kuhukumu juu ya mbinu (ambayo ni seti ya kanuni za Kishari'ah na si mitindo) kwamba inaweza kufanyiwa majaribio? Kwamba ikishajaribiwa na ikaleta matunda, ndipo tunaihukumu kuwa sahihi, na kama haikuleta matunda, basi ni batili?
Another question also arises, which is: is it correct to judge on the method (which is a set of Shar’ee rules and not styles) as being subject to experiment? If after trying it, it gives fruit then we judge it to be correct, otherwise it is incorrect?