14.1 譬喻(Mathal)
14.1 The Mathal
虽然“مَثَل”(mathal)一词通常被译为明喻或隐喻,但在《古兰经》的语境中,它还包括谚语,甚至包括典范。因此,依伊斯兰学科的定义,mathal是一段简练而动人、富有感染力的文辞,借它表达某种理念,不论其结构如何。《古兰经》中的mathal主要有三种基本形式:明示的譬喻(musarrah mathal)、隐含的譬喻(kaamin mathal)和无固定形式的譬喻(mursal mathal)。11
Although the term mathal is commonly translated as simile or metaphor, in the context of the Qur’aan it includes proverbs, and even ideals. Hence, the definition of a mathal according to the Islaamic sciences is a concise but impressive and moving literary passage in which an idea is expressed, regardless of its construction. The mathal in the Qur’aan comes in three basic forms, the musarrah mathal (stated), the kaamin mathal (hidden), and the mursal mathal (formless).11
1. 明确表述的譬喻(Mathal Musarrah)
1. The Mathal Musarrah (Stated)
这种形式,顾名思义,包含明显的比较,在《古兰经》中广泛使用。12 在描述那些假装信奉伊斯兰教的伪信者时所使用的火与水的比喻和隐喻中,就可以找到这样的例子:
This form, as the name implies, contains an obvious comparison and is widely used in the Qur’aan.12 Such examples may be found in the fire and water similes and metaphors used in reference to the hypocrites who feign Islaam:
“他们好比点火的人,火光照亮了他周围,真主就夺去了他们的光明,使他们陷在一片漆黑之中,什么也看不见。他们是聋的、哑的、瞎的,所以他们不会回到正路上来。或者好比天空中的暴雨云,伴有雷鸣和闪电,雷声一响,他们因怕死而把手指塞进耳朵里。但真主是包围着不信道者的。闪电几乎要夺去他们的视力;每当闪电为他们照亮时,他们就走几步;等四周变黑时,他们就停在那里。假若真主意欲,他必能夺去他们的听觉和视觉,因为真主对每一件事都有大能。”13
“They are like one who kindles a fire; then when it lights up what is around him, Allaah takes away his light and leaves him in total darkness in which he cannot see (anything). They are deaf, dumb, and blind; hence, they will never return to the path. Or like a dark rain cloud, thundering and flashing lightning in the sky, (during which) they stick their fingers in their ears from the thunderclap, fearing death. But Allaah surrounds the disbelievers. The lightning almost snatches away their sight, but every time it lights up (the area) for them, they walk, and when it becomes dark, they stand still. If Allaah had willed, He could have taken away their hearing and sight, for certainly Allaah is able to do all things.” 13
火之所以在此段文字中被使用,是因其光明的特质;水之所以被使用,是因其能使大地复苏。火与水确实象征着各种元素。
Fire is used in this passage due to its quality of light, and water is used due to its ability to bring earth back to life. Fire and water really represent the elements.
启示从天而降,用以照亮人心、使人心重获生机。在这些经文中,安拉以火和水来说明启示对那些假装做穆斯林之人的影响。那些为了从伊斯兰中获取世俗利益而皈依的伪信者,就像点燃一把火以取其温暖和光亮的人。然而,他们进入伊斯兰对其内心并没有任何照亮的作用;同样,安拉也使火失去光的属性,只留下热的属性。因此,他们身处一片漆黑之中,眼盲心盲,无法看见真理。伪信者还像身处暴风雨中的人,因闪电而害怕死亡,又试图躲避那震碎心神的雷鸣。伪信者在安拉的话语降示于他们时,非但没有因此而在精神上复活,反而试图屏蔽那雷鸣般的命令与禁令,因为他们害怕顺服这些命令和禁令,就意味着他们的灵魂与私欲将走向死亡。
Revelation was sent down from the heavens to enlighten human hearts and bring them to life. In these verses, Allaah uses fire and water to explain the effect of revelation on those who pretend to be Muslims. The hypocrites who enter Islaam so as to benefit from it materially are like someone who lights a fire in order to benefit from its warmth and light. However, their entrance into Islaam has no enlightening effect on their hearts; likewise, Allaah removes the quality of light from the fire leaving only its quality of heat. Hence, they are in total darkness, blind, unable to see the truth. The hypocrites are also like someone in a rainstorm fearing death from its flashes of lightning and trying to avoid its mind-shattering thunderclap. Instead of coming to life spiritually when God’s word is revealed to them, the hypocrites try to block out its thundering commands and prohibitions, fearing that submission to them would mean the death of their souls and egos.
另一个关于火与水的比喻,见于下面这节经文,它涉及真理与虚妄。
Another mathal involving fire and water can be found in the following verse concerning truth and falsehood.
"他从天上降下雨水,河谷便依其容量而流淌,洪流载着泛起的泡沫。在他们为了制作饰物或器具而用火熔炼的矿石中,也有类似的泡沫。真主就这样为真理与虚妄作比喻。泡沫终将被抛弃而消失,而那对人有益的,则留存于大地上。真主就这样设立比喻。"14
“He sends down water from the skies which flows in valleys according to their capacities, and the flood carries swelling froth on its surface; there is a similar froth in the (ore) which they heat in the fire in order to make ornaments or implements. In this way, Allaah makes a comparison between truth and falsehood. For the froth is thrown away and disappears, while that which is beneficial to man remains on earth. In this way, Allaah makes parables.” 14
再次强调,启示被比作降下的雨水,它被降下是为了使心灵复活,正如雨水降下使大地借植物而复苏。人的心灵就是比喻中大小不一的山谷,启示之洪流便依照各自的容量在其中流淌。正如洪水在其奔流中裹挟着大地上的泡沫与浮渣,知识与正道的指引也流注于心灵之上,以洗去卑劣的欲望。心灵又被比作各种不同的矿石,如金、银、铁、铜等,它们经火的熨烫而得以提纯。杂质以泡沫和浮渣的形式浮至表面而被舍弃,留下纯净的金属。同样,当信士的心灵受到启示之热力与光明的照耀时,邪恶的欲望便被抛弃,心灵也就得到了净化。
Once again, revelation, which is sent down to bring hearts to life, is likened to water coming down to bring the earth to life with plants. Human hearts are the metaphorical valleys of varying sizes in which the flood of revelation flows accordingly. As the physical flood carries the froth and scum of the earth in its currents, so guidance and knowledge flow upon the hearts to wash away base desires. Hearts are then likened to different types of ore, such as gold, silver, iron, copper, etc., which are purified by the heat of the fire. Impurities rise to the surface in the form of froth and scum which are discarded, leaving the pure metal behind. Likewise, when the hearts of believers are exposed to the heat and light of revelation, evil desires are cast off and the hearts are purified.
在上述两个例子中,火与启示之间、水与启示之间的比喻关系都是显而易见的。比较介词“like”以及“比较”“譬喻”“比喻”等词都明确出现,因此这些段落的用意毫无疑问。
In both of the examples given above, the comparison between both fire and revelation and water and revelation is obvious. The comparative preposition “like” and the words “comparison, parable, simile” are all mentioned, leaving no doubt as to the intent of the passages.
2. 隐藏的比喻(Mathal Kaamin)
2. The Mathal Kaamin (Hidden)
在这种形式中,不使用比较的词语。15 然而,这一类比喻(mathal)所传达的伊斯兰理念,因其蕴含的深刻而动人的意义,能够轻易地被人类的天性所接受。例如,两个极端之间的中道理念,在《古兰经》的许多经文中都得到了优美的表达。在花费财物方面,安拉赞扬那些
In this form, the terms of comparison are not used.15 However, this type of mathal conveys Islaamic ideals readily acceptable to natural human instincts due to the deep and impressive meanings which they imply. For example, the concept of the middle road between the two extremes is beautifully expressed in many verses of the Qur’aan. In the case of spending, Allaah praises those
“他们花费的时候,既不奢侈,也不吝啬,而是在两者之间保持中道。”16
“Who are neither extravagant nor stingy when they spend; but between that is a just stand.” 16
至于礼拜(ṣalāh),真主指示说:
And in the case of salaah, Allaah advises:
“不要在你的礼拜中大声诵读,也不要过于低声,而要在两者之间寻求一条中道。”17
“Do not be loud voiced nor extremely soft in your salaah, but seek a path between them.” 17
另一个优美表达的例子,是“听闻不等同于亲见”这一观念。在西方,这一观念的更极端版本常被引用为:“眼见为实。”然而,生活中有太多我们不曾亲眼所见却仍然相信的事物(磁力、心灵、风等),因此这句话并不准确。伊斯兰的原则是:亲眼见到某物所产生的信念,比仅仅听闻此事更为坚定。因此,当易卜拉欣先知请求安拉让他看到祂如何使死者复活时,安拉说:
Another example of beautiful expression may be found in the concept that hearing is not like seeing. In the West, a more extreme version of this concept is often quoted as, “Seeing is believing.” However, life is too full of instances where we believe in things without seeing them (magnetism, the mind, wind, etc.) for that saying to be accurate. The Islaamic precept is that seeing a thing produces a stronger belief than merely hearing about it. Hence, when Prophet Ibraaheem requested that Allaah show him how He brings life to the dead, Allaah said,
“你不信吗?”他回答说:“当然信,但亲眼看见能让我的心得到安宁。”18
“Do you not believe?” He replied, “Of course (I believe), but (seeing) would put my heart at rest.” 18
3. 无形之喻(Al-Mathal Al-Mursal)
3. The Mathal Mursal (Formless)
本形式涵盖一些简短的经文,它们传达教训,其中许多已成为谚语。与“隐喻式譬喻”(mathal kaamin)一样,它没有明显的譬喻词或比喻句式;不过,其中可能包含比较,或暗含比较。19 以下经文清楚地说明了这一类譬喻:
This form covers short verses which convey lessons, many of which have become proverbs. Like the mathal kaamin, it has none of the expressions or similes; however, comparisons may be made or implied.19 The following verses clearly illustrate this type of mathal:
“也许你们厌恶某件事,而它对你们却是有益的。”(2:216)
“Perhaps you may dislike something which is good for you.” 20
“善的回报,难道不是善吗?”21
“Is the reward for good anything but good?” 21
“污秽的与纯良的不相等。”22
“The foul and the wholesome are not equal.” 22
“多少次,一小群人在安拉的许可下战胜了一大群人。” 23
“How often a small group has defeated a larger group by Allaah’s permission.” 23
“你以为他们是团结的,但他们的心是分散的。”24
“You think they are united, but their hearts are scattered.” 24
《古兰经》中使用比喻(mathal)所获得的益处有许多。25 无形的概念以有形的方式呈现,使人们更容易理解和记住。那些在理论上可能很难把握的概念,一旦用人类日常经验或自然界的过程来表述,就能迅速而轻易地被理解。例如,"为炫耀而施舍钱财的人得不到任何回报"这一观念,通过以下比喻得以具体地传达:
The benefits gained from the use of the mathal in the Qur’aan are numerous.25 Intangible concepts are presented in a tangible format in order for them to be more easily grasped and retained. Concepts which may be quite difficult to grasp on a theoretical basis become quickly and easily comprehensible when put in the terms of everyday human experiences or processes in nature. For example, the idea that one who gives money for show gains no reward is tangibly brought across by the following simile:
"它们就像覆盖着一层泥土的岩石,被暴雨猛烈冲刷,留下光秃秃的石面。他们对自己所赚得的财富,一无所能。" 26
“They are like a rock covered with some earth which is struck by a rainstorm, leaving it bare. They are unable to do anything with (the wealth) they have earned.” 26
有时,人们会运用“مثل”(比喻)来鼓励人们去做某些善行,将其比作对人的天性具有吸引力的事物。这一作用的一个例子可见于以下经文:
Sometimes the mathal is used to encourage people to do certain righteous acts by comparing them to something which is appealing to human nature. An example of this function may be found in the verse:
“那些在真主之道上施舍财产的人,就像一粒麦种,长出七个穗子,每个穗子上有一百粒种子。真主使他所意欲的人加倍增益。”27
“Those who spend their wealth in Allaah’s path are like a corn seed which sprouts seven ears, each ear containing one hundred seeds. Allaah multiplies (the gifts) of whomsoever He wishes.” 27
有时,人们会运用譬喻(mathal),把某些恶劣的行为比作令人厌恶的事物,以此劝阻人们去做这些事。例如,安拉在谈到背后诽谤他人时说:
At other times, the mathal is used to discourage certain evil practices by comparing them to distasteful things. For example, Allaah said the following concerning backbiting:
“不要彼此背后议论。你们中有谁喜欢吃他死去兄弟的肉呢?你们厌恶它……” 28
“Do not backbite each other. Would anyone of you wish to eat the flesh of his dead brother? You detest it...” 28
我们所有人一想到要吃死去兄弟的肉都会感到厌恶,当我们听到诽谤或背后说人坏话时,也应当有这样的厌恶之感。
The revulsion we all feel at the thought of eating the flesh of our dead brother should be felt when we hear slander or backbiting.
mathal(譬喻)也可用来赞扬某些类型的人,或贬斥、羞辱另一些人,从而确立可接受的行为准则。比喻通常比直接的命令和详尽的解释更能打动人、更有说服力。因此,真主在《古兰经》中多次运用比喻:
The mathal may also be used to praise certain types of individuals or disgrace and debase others in order to set up certain standards of acceptable behavior. Figurative speech is generally a more moving and effective method of communica-tion than direct commands and detailed explanations. Hence, Allaah has used them frequently in the Qur’aan:
“我确已在《古兰经》中为世人设了各种譬喻(mathal),或许他们会深思。”29
“Certainly I have made all kinds of parables (mathal) in the Qur’aan for mankind that perhaps they would reflect.” 29
还有许多例子表明,先知(r)在言论中依靠譬喻(mathal)来传达他的信息。30
There are also numerous examples in the statements of the Prophet (r) where he relied on the mathal to get his message across. 30
《古兰经学研究》第293页。
11 Mabaahith fee ‘Uloom al-Qur’aan, p. 293.
12 Al-Itqaan, vol.4, p. 39. Note: Following the instructions, this is a citation label, so I'm translating it as text. Here is the translation: 12《Al-Itqaan》,第4卷,第39页。
12 Al-Itqaan, vol.4, p. 39.
**Sūrat al-Baqarah(2):17–20** 这些人的比喻,好比点火的人,火光照亮了他四周,安拉却夺去了他们的光明,使他们在黑暗中看不见。他们聋、哑、瞎,所以不会回头。 或者,他们的比喻好比天空中的暴雨,其中有黑暗、雷声和闪电,他们因怕死而把手指塞进耳朵里,安拉是包围不信道者的。 闪电几乎夺去他们的视力;每当闪电照亮他们的时候,他们就在光中行走;天色暗下来的时候,他们就站住。假若安拉意欲,必定夺去他们的听觉和视觉。安拉对于万事,确是全能的。
13 Soorah al-Baqarah (2):17-20.
14 Sūrat ar-Ra‘d (13):17
14 Soorah ar-Ra‘d (13):17.
《伊particular》? No, let me translate faithfully: 15 《Al-Itqaan》,第4卷,第41页。
15 Al-Itqaan, vol.4, p. 41.
《古兰经》古兰经 25:67
16 Soorah al-Furqaan (25):67.
第十七章 伊斯拉(夜行)章(17):110
17 Soorah al-Israa’ (17):110.
第二章 黄牛(Al-Baqarah):260
18 Soorah al-Baqarah (2):260.
《古兰学精义》(Al-Itqaan),第4卷,第43页。
19 Al-Itqaan, vol. 4, p. 43.
第二章 黄牛章(2:216)
20 Soorah al-Baqarah (2):216.
Sūrat al-Raḥmān (55):60
21 Soorah ar-Rahmaan (55):60.
第22 章 《筵席》(al-Maa’idah)(5):100
22 Soorah al-Maa’idah (5):100.
23 Sūrah al-Baqarah (2):249.
23 Soorah al-Baqarah (2):249.
24 Soorah al-Hashr (59):14. Translation: 古兰经第59章《放逐》第14节。
24 Soorah al-Hashr (59):14.
25 参见《古兰经学研究》(Mabaahith fee ‘Uloom al-Qur’aan),第297-299页。
25 See Mabaahith fee ‘Uloom al-Qur’aan, pp. 297-9.
26 Sūrat al-Baqarah (2):264
26 Soorah al-Baqarah (2):264.
《古兰经》第二章 黄牛(Al-Baqarah)第261节
27 Soorah al-Baqarah (2):261.
28 Soorah al-Hujuraat (49):12. Note: this is a label/reference, translated as it appears. Translation: 第四十九章 al-Hujuraat(寝室)第 12 节
28 Soorah al-Hujuraat (49):12.
29 Soorah az-Zumar (39):27. Note: the input is a Qur'an reference label, which the system rules say to translate as is. Translation: 第39章 az-Zumar(39):27
29 Soorah az-Zumar (39):27.
30 他们的数量太多,无法一一列举,这里仅举一个小例子:先知用一个比喻,把遵守安拉所定界限的人与不遵守的人,比作一艘船上层甲板与下层甲板上的人(《圣训实录》,布哈里辑,第3卷,第406页,第673条)。另请参阅《圣训实录》,布哈里辑,第1卷,第278页,第……条。
30 They are too numerous to begin to list, but just as a tiny sample, refer to the simile of the people who observe the limits set by Allaah and those who don’t as people on the upper and lower decks of a ship (Sahih Al-Bukhari, vol. 3, p. 406, no. 673). See also Sahih Al-Bukhari, vol. 1, p. 278, no.
**468**,关于信士如同一座建筑,其中的砖块彼此支撑的比喻。
468, for a simile of the believers as a structure whose bricks support each other.