Shubhasiz, islohotchi/progressiv musulmonlarga javob berish shartmi? Unchalik emas. Ular bilan bahsga kirishish behuda mashg'ulotdir, chunki ularning usuli yo'q. Ular turli-tuman, g'alati fikrlarga keladigan aniq, ravshan tamoyillarga ega emas. Shuning uchun ularni biror narsaga bog'lashga urinsangiz, tezda boshqa mavzuga o'tib ketishadi va suhbat hech qayerga bormaydi. Buni tajribamdan aytyapman… Ko'p marta peshonamni ushlab qolganman… Ammo islohotchi/progressiv musulmonlar bilan shug'ullanmasdan ham, ularning barcha qarashlarini butunlay rad etish mumkin. Buning uchun ularning mafkurasining ildiziga, ya'ni liberal, modernistik tafakkurga hujum qilish kerak. Bu esa vaqtingizga arziydigan ish. Quyidagi misolni ko'rib chiqing.

Is it necessary to provide a rebuttal to so-called reformist/ progressive Muslims? Not really. If you try to engage in debate with them, it is a fruitless exercise because they have no usul. They have no clear, explicit principles they use to derive all the strange, divergent opinions they come up with. So if you try to hold them to something, they quickly pivot to something else and the conversation goes nowhere. I speak from experience… A lot of face-palming experience… But you don’t need to engage reformist/progressive Muslims in order to completely debunk everything they stand for. You do this by attacking the root of their ideology: liberal, modernist thought. That is something worth spending your time on. Consider this example.