Noto'g'ri o'xshatish: LGBT guruhlari musulmonlar huquqlarini himoya qiladi, shuning uchun musulmon guruhlari ham bir jinsli nikohni, transgender hojatxonalar to'g'risidagi qonun loyihalarini, murojaat olmoshlarini tanlashni va boshqalarni himoya qilishi kerak. Bu nima uchun noto'g'ri o'xshatish? Chunki LGBT guruhlari himoya qiladigan musulmon huquqlari LGBT mafkurasiga zid emas. Musulmonlarning masjid qurish huquqi LGBT mafkurasiga zid emas. Musulmonlarning AQShga kirishi taqiqlanmasligi ham LGBT mafkurasiga zid emas va hokazo.

False analogy: LGBT groups advocate for Muslim rights therefore Muslim groups should advocate for same-sex marriage, transgender bathroom bills, pronoun preference, etc. Why is it a false analogy? Because the particular Muslim rights LGBT groups advocate for are not contrary to LGBT ideology. Muslims being able to build mosques is not contrary to LGBT ideology. Muslims not being banned from travel to the US is not contrary to LGBT ideology, etc.

Lekin bir jinsli nikoh, gender me'yorlarining buzilishi, "LGBT turmush tarzi"ning targʻib qilinishi Islomga zid. Shuning uchun bu adolatli kelishuvdan juda uzoqda.

But same-sex marriage, the dissolution of gender norms, the promotion of “LGBT lifestyles” are contrary to Islam. So it’s nowhere close to being a fair deal.

Agar vaziyatni adolatli qilmoqchi bo'lsak, LGBT guruhlari Islomiy tamoyillarni va musulmonlarning sohalariga oid tashabbuslarni qo'llab-quvvatlashga tayyor bo'lishi kerak, hatto ular LGBT mafkurasiga zid bo'lsa ham. Masalan, LGBT "ittifoqchilari" musulmon tadbirlari va tashabbuslarini qo'llab-quvvatlaydimi, ular islomiy gender me'yorlarini mustahkamlaydimi? Masalan, ular musulmon jamoasi ichida ayollarning an'anaviy islomiy roli — ona sifatida, erkaklarning esa oila boquvchisi sifatida — targ'ib qiladigan tadbirlar, ta'lim va materiallarga hamkorlik qilishga tayyormi? Ular musulmon mamlakatlarida "gender tengligi"ga oid liberal qarashlarga zid bo'lgan siyosatlarni homiylik qilarmidilar, masalan, musulmon ayollarning g'ayrimusulmon erkaklarga turmushga chiqishini taqiqlovchi qonunlarni yoki Shariat bo'yicha merosni jinslar o'rtasida taqsimlashni tasdiqlovchi qonunlarni? Aslida vaziyatni to'liq o'xshash qilish uchun LGBT guruhlari musulmonlarning islomiy jinsiy me'yorlarni, jumladan, bir jinsli munosabatlarni taqiqlashni saqlab qolishini qo'llab-quvvatlashi kerak. Shunda bu haqiqiy "bir-birimizga yordam beramiz" holati bo'lardi. Musulmonlar bir jinsli nikohni targ'ib qilish orqali o'z axloqiy me'yorlarini buzadi, LGBT guruhlari esa bir jinsli xatti-harakatga qarshi xatti-harakatni targ'ib qilish orqali o'z jinsiy axloqini buzadi. Mukammal tenglik. Faqat LGBT guruhlari ushbu islomiy tamoyillarni musulmonlarning amalga oshirishini hevesle qo'llab-quvvatlasa, homiylik qilsa va moliyalashtirsa, shundagina musulmonlardan bir jinsli nikohni va boshqa narsalarni qo'llab-quvvatlashni talab qilish o'xshash bo'lardi.

If we want to make this a fair situation, we would have to see if LGBT groups are willing to support Muslim causes and Islamic principles that do contradict LGBT ideology. For example, are LGBT “allies” willing to support Muslim events and causes that reinforce Islamic gender norms? For example, would they be willing to co-sponsor events, education, material that promote within the Muslim community the traditional Islamic role of women as mothers and men as breadwinners? Would they be willing to sponsor policies in Muslim countries that contravene liberal views on “gender equality,” e.g., laws that prohibit Muslim women from marrying non-Muslim men, laws that uphold the Sharia’s distribution of inheritance between the genders, etc.? In fact, to make it perfectly analogous, LGBT groups should support Muslims’ upholding of Islamic sexual norms, including the prohibition of same-sex behavior. That would make it a true “I scratch your back, you scratch my back” situation. Muslims violate their sexual ethics by advocating for LGBT normalization, LGBT groups violate their sexual ethics by advocating for the normalization of anti-same-sex behavior. Perfect parity. If and only if LGBT groups were enthusiastically endorsing, supporting, and sponsoring Muslims’ upholding of these Islamic principles, would it be analogous to demand Muslims to support same-sex marriage, etc.

Bu gap hech qachon sodir bo'lmaydi, shuning uchun ahmoqona dalillarni takrorlab, fahshoning tarqalishiga qo'shgan hissangizni oqlashni to'xtating.

But it’s never going to happen, so stop parroting asinine arguments to justify your contribution to the spread of fahisha.