Sa'ad da khabar ahad ta saɓa wa ayoyi da hadisai tabbatattu, sai a ƙi karɓar ilimin khabar ahad ɗin. Saboda haka, babu la'akari da abin da aka riwaito cewa Manzon Allah ﷺ ya yi bauta (bautar da mutane) bayan saukar ayar fursuna. Ainihin abin da ya faru a yakin Hunain shi ne, mata da yara sun bi mayaƙan mushrikai don ƙara yawan su da kuma tada hankalin mazajensu. Don haka, da aka fatattake su a fagen yaƙi, sai mata da yara suka zama fursunoni, Manzon Allah ﷺ kuma ya raba su tsakanin mayaƙan Musulmi. Da aka sake duba wannan game da fursunonin, Musulmi sun yi kyautar abin da suka mallaka na hakki a cikin fursunonin (sabaya) da yardar ransu, sun kuma mayar da fursunonin (sabaya) ga mutanensu. Wannan ya nuna halascin bautar da (sabaya), wato mata da yara da suke bin mazaje a fagen yaƙi don ƙara yawan su da kuma ƙarfafa su. Duk da haka, Manzon Allah ﷺ bai bautar da matan da yaran da suka bi mayaƙa a Khaibar ba. Lokacin da ya ﷺ ya kai farmaki Khaibar ya ci ta, ya bar su a matsayin 'yantattu, ya kuma bar ƙasar a hannunsu don su noma ta da rabin amfaninta. Abu Ubaidah ya ce game da fursunonin (sabaya): "Shugaba yana da zaɓi a kansu muddin ba a raba su ba. Da zarar an raba su, babu wata hanya a kansu sai ta kyauta da yardar ran waɗanda suka zama nasu, kamar aikin Manzon Allah ﷺ da mutanen Hunain. Babu ɗaya daga cikin fursunonin (sabaya) da aka mayar ta hannun kowa daga cikinsu sai ta kyauta da yardar rai, tun da ya raba su. Bai yi haka da mutanen Khaibar ba, sai dai ya bar su a matsayin 'yantattu, kuma ba wanda ya ba da su kyauta, domin ba a yi rabo a kansu ba."
And when the (khabr ahad) contradicts the definite ayat and ahadith the knowledge of the (khabr ahad) is rejected. Accordingly, there is no consideration to what is narrated about the Messenger (saw) enslaving after the revelation of the ayah of captives. Actually what happened in the battle of Hunain is that the women and children accompanied the fighters of the polytheists to increase their numbers and incite their men, so when they were routed in the battlefield the women and children became captives and the Messenger (saw) divided them between the fighters among the Muslims. When this was revised regarding the captives, the Muslims gifted what they had of the right in the captives (sabaya) voluntarily and returned their captives (sabaya) to their people. This indicated the permissibility of enslaving (sabaya) who are the women and children who accompany the men in the battlefield to increase the numbers and for encouragement. Despite that, the Messenger (saw) did not enslave the women and children who accompanied the fighters in Khayber. When he (saw) invaded Khayber and conquered it, he left them as free persons and left the land under their hands to farm it for half its produce. Abu Ubaidah said about the captives (sabaya): ‘The Imam is given a choice about them as long as they have not been divided. Once they are divided there is no way over them except by gift and free will of those for whom they become like the action of the Messenger of Allah (saw) with the people of Hunain. None of the captives (sabaya) were returned by anyone of them except by gift and free will since he had divided them. He did not do this with the people of Khayber but rather left them as free persons nor were they gifted by anyone as division had not occurred over them.
Dangane da waɗanda ba su ne sabaya ba, waɗanda su ne mayaƙa idan an kama su, Manzon Allah ﷺ bai taɓa mayar da wani daga cikin mazajensu bawa ba. Ba a tabbatar da cewa ya mayar da wani mayaƙin yaƙi daga cikin Larabawa, ko Yahudawa, ko Nasara bawa ba. Kalmar (aseer) idan aka yi amfani da ita ba tare da takurawa ba a harshe, tana nufin mayaƙin namiji. Amma ga mace da yaro, kalmar da ake amfani da ita a kansu a harshe ita ce yara (sabiyy), ba fursuna ba (usra). Saboda haka wannan ya bayyana cewa Musulunci ya hana mayar da waɗanda aka kama daga mayaƙan maza bayi, kuma ya ba Khalifa zaɓi game da yara (sabaya) tsakanin mayar da su bayi da kuma 'yantar da su, kuma babu fansa a kansu. Kamar yadda Manzon Allah ﷺ ya yi a sabayan Hunaini: ya mayar da su bayi, sannan ya 'yantar da su. Kuma kamar yadda ya yi da sabayan Khaibar: ya bar su 'yanci ba tare da mayar da su bayi ba. Wannan yana kasancewa idan mata da yara suna tare da runduna a yaƙi; idan kuwa sun zauna a gida, to babu wani abu a kansu, ba fursuna ba, ba kuma sabaya ba. Aikin Khalifa game da batun mayar da sabaya bayi yana bin abin da manufofin yaƙi suke bukata wajen mu'amala da abokan gāba. Manufarsa ba mayar da su bayi ba ce, sai dai yana ɗaya daga cikin mu'amalolin yaƙi da al'amarinsa ya rataya ga Khalifa, wanda yake yin abin da ya gani, da abin da matsayinsa dangane da abokan gāba ke bukata.
As for other than the captives (sabaya) who are the fighters when they are captured, the Messenger (saw) never enslaved any of their men. It is not authenticated that he enslaved a prisoner of war of the fighting men from the Arabs or Jews or Christians. The word (aseer) when used unrestricted in the language relates to the male fighter. As for the woman and the child, the word used for them in the language is children (sabiyy) and not prisoner of war (usra). Accordingly this clarifies that Islam prevented enslaving captives from the male fighters, and gave the Khalifah a choice in the children (sabaya) between enslaving and liberation and there is no ransom for them. Just as the Messenger (saw) did in the sabaya of Hunain; he enslaved them then liberated them. And like he did with the sabaya of Khayber; he left them free without enslaving them. This is if women and children accompany the army in war; if they stay at home, however, there is nothing upon them, prisoner of war nor captives. The action of the Khalifah in the question of enslaving the sabaya proceeds according to what the war policy requires in dealing with the enemy. Its objective is not enslaving rather it is merely one of the war transactions whose matter is left to the Khalifah who does what he sees and what the position in relation to the enemy requires.
Saboda haka wannan ya bayyana cewa Musulunci ya hana bautar da mutane, kuma ya hana duk wani yanayi da bauta za ta faru, sannan ya bar wa Khalifah zabi a cikin yanayin sabaya, bisa ga matsayinsa game da abokan gaba. Don haka ya kawo karshen bautar mutane, musamman lokacin da ya soke yadda ake fitar da mata da yara tare da sojoji don kara yawan mutane da karfafa gwiwa, kamar yadda ake yi a yakin zamani tsawon shekaru aru-aru har zuwa yau. Babu sauran wani yanayi ko daya da bauta za ta iya faruwa. Saboda haka Musulunci ya hana bauta.
Accordingly this clarifies that Islam treated enslaving and prevented all situation in which enslaving occurred and left for the Khalifah the choice in the situation of sabaya in following the position in relation to the enemy. Hence it has finished enslaving particularly when it invalidated the women and children going out with the army to increase the numbers and for encouragement as in the situation in modern warfare for centuries today. There does not remain even one situation in which enslaving occurs at all. Accordingly Islam has prevented enslaving.