Idan Ijma'i ya tabbata a kan wani Hukunci na wata Mas'ala (batun shari'a), sannan wannan Siffa (siffa ko halayyar bayani) da ke cikin batun ta canja, to shin Hukuncin batun yana nan kamar yadda yake ne? Malamai sun sha banban game da wannan.
If Ijmaa’ occurs upon a Hukm of a particular Mas’alah (issue) and that Siffah (descriptive element/attribute) that is in the issue changes, then does the Hukm of the issue remain as it is? They (the ‘Ulamaa) have differed in respect to that.
Menene hukuncin wanda ya yi tayammum saboda rashin ruwa, sannan ya gano ruwa yana cikin salla? Kuma ta yaya ya kamata ya yi game da ko ya cika sallarsa ko kuma bai cika ba?
What is the Hukm if the one who has made Tayammum due to the absence of water discovered water during his prayer? And how should he act in respect to completing his Salaah or not completing it?
A – Abu Haneefah ya ce sallarsa ta ɓaci idan ya ga ruwa, kuma wajibi ne a gare shi yin alwala, sannan ya ci gaba da sallarsa. Abu Haamid Al-Ghazaaliy, Abu At-Tayyib At-Tabari, Ibn As-Sabaagh da sauran malaman fiqhu su ma sun amince da wannan ra'ayi.
B – Amma Ash-Shaafi'iy, shi ya ce sallarsa ingantacciya ce, kuma ganin ruwa a lokacin sallah ba shi da wani tasiri a kan sallarsa. Wannan ra'ayi kuma Dawood Azh-Zhaahiriy, Al-Aamadiy da Ibn ul-Haajib suka tabbatar, a cikin wasu.
A – Abu Haneefah views that his Salaah is invalidated upon the sighting of the water and Wudoo’ is necessary for him and to resume his Salaah. Abu Haamid Al-Ghazaaliy, Abu At-Tayyib At-Tabari, Ibn As-Sabaagh and other Fuqahaa’ also agreed with this opinion. B – As for Ash-Shaafi’iy then he viewed that his Salaah is Saheeh (valid) and the sighting of the water during his prayer has no impact or effect upon his Salaah. This opinion was also upheld by Dawood Azh-Zhaahiriy, Al-Aamadiy and Ibn ul-Haajib amongst others.
At-Tarjeeh (Rinjaye):
At-Tarjeeh (outweighing):
- Ɓacin ingancin Tayammum idan ruwa ya kasance ga wanda ya yi Tayammum saboda rashin ruwa yana tabbata ne da nassi ba da ijma'i ba.
- Idan wanda ya yi Tayammum ya shiga Sallah yana ci gaba da halin rashin ruwa (Istishaab), sai ya fara Sallarsa yana cika sharuddan ingancinta gaba ɗaya, kuma ba ya fita daga Sallar sai da abin da yake ɓata ta. Ganin ruwa ba ya karya Sallah ko ɓata ta, kuma Sallah aiki ɗaya ne mai ci gaba, wanda ya fara da Takbiratul-Ihram ya ƙare da Sallama. Saboda haka, Sallarsa tana karɓuwa a gare shi matuƙar ya cika sharuddan ingancinta.
- The invalidity of At-Tayammum when water is present of the one who has made Tayammum due to the absence of water is established by the text and not by Ijmaa’. - When the one who made Tayammum entered into the state of the Salaah he was continuing upon (Istishaab) the case of the absence of the water and so he began his Salaah having met the conditions of its validity in full (completely) and he does not exit from his Salaah apart from by that which invalidates it. Seeing water does not break or invalidate the prayer and the prayer is one continuous action beginning with the Takbeer Al-Ihraam and ending with Salaam. Therefore, his performance of the Salaah counts for him as long as he had fulfilled the conditions for its validity.