Malamai sun sha banban game da Hujjiyyar (ingancin hujja a matsayin tushen dokoki) na Shar'u Min Qablinaa wanda aka ambata a cikin Shari'armu ba tare da musantawa ko tabbatarwa ba (goyon baya). Shin mu ma ana yi mana magana da shi ko a'a? Ra'ayoyinsu game da wannan sune kamar haka:

The ‘Ulamaa have differed in respect to the Hujjiyah (legal validity as a source) of the Shar’u Min Qablinaa that has been mentioned in our Share’ah without denial or affirmation (support). Are we addressed by it or not? Their opinions in regards to this are as follows:

1 – Mafi yawan malaman Ahnaaf, da Maalikiyah, da wasu daga cikin Shaafi'iyyah, tare da Ahmad a wata magana da aka danganta gare shi, sun tabbatar da cewa Shar'u Min Qablinaa, wato shari'ar da aka ambata a cikin Shari'armu ba tare da Inkaar (musantawa ko tsawatarwa) ba kuma ba tare da Ta'yeed (goyon baya ba), ita ma shari'a ce a gare mu, kuma muna da wajibcin bin ta. Domin tabbatar da ra'ayinsu, sun yi amfani da Qawlin Allah Ta'aalaa a matsayin dalili: