Xuddi shunday, biror ishning nahiy (man qilinishi) uning aksini bajarishga amr (buyruq) ifodalamaydi.
Similarly, The Nahi (forbiddance) Of A Matter Does Not Represent An Amr (command) To Do Its Opposite
Nahiy (qaytarish) bir ishning buyrug'i emas, ya'ni u ishning aksini qilishga buyruq emas, chunki tilda Nahiy shakli (taqiq shakli) aynan ish-harakatdan qaytish talabini bildirish uchun joriy qilingan. Bu talab qat'iy yoki qat'iy bo'lmagan tarzda bo'lishi mumkin va u harom va makruhni o'z ichiga oladi.
The Nahi of a matter is not a command to do the opposite because the Seeghat un-Nahi (forbiddance form) has been provided in the language to indicate the Talab Tark Al-F’il (The request to leave or not do the action) in a decisive or indecisive manner whilst it includes the Haraam and the Makrooh within it.
Shunga ko'ra, Allohning Qavli — Ta'olo hazratlari — borasida:
Consequently, in respect to the Qawl of Allah Ta’Aalaa:
Shuning uchun ularga (ota-onangizga) "Uff" demang (Al-Isro 23).
So do not say to them (parents) Uff (Al-Israa’ 23).
Parents'ga nisbatan at-ta'fif (norozilik va nafrat bildirish) ning nahiysi, at-ta'fifning aksini qilish haqidagi amrni anglatmaydi. Ya'ni: "Ularga 'Uff' demang" degani "Ularga 'Uff'dan boshqasini ayting" degani emas. Xuddi shunday, bu "Ularga 'Uff'dan boshqasini aytish vojib" degani ham emas. Buning sababi shuki, haromdan tiyilish yoki uni tark etish farz degani emas, va nahiy amr bilan, ya'ni nahiyga zid bo'lgan narsaga amr qilish bilan bir ma'noda emas. Chunki nahiy lug'atda ish qilishdan tiyilishni so'rashni anglatadi, harom qilingan ishga qarama-qarshi ishni bajarishga amr qilishni emas.
The Nahi (forbiddance) of At-Ta’feef (expressing displeasure/disdain) towards the parents, does not mean the command to do the opposite of At-Ta’feef. So: ‘Do not say to them Uff’ does not mean: ‘Say to them other than Uff’. Just as it does not mean that the Waajib (obligation)is to say to them other than ‘Uff’ and that is because the leaving or abstention from Haraam does not mean the Fard and because the Nahi does not mean the command with opposite to the Nahi. That is because the Nahi linguistically means the request to abstain from undertaking the action whilst it does not mean the command to undertake the action opposite to the action that has been forbidden.
Fard va haram hukmlari qanday bo'lsa, mandub va makruh hukmlari ham xuddi shunday tarzda amal qiladi.
What applies in respect to the Fard and the Haraam applies in the same way upon the Mandoob and the Makrooh.