《The General》的限定性证据 (Adillah Takhsees Al-‘aamm)
Adillah Takhsees Al-‘aamm (evidences Of Specifying The General)
以下为“specifying the general”(以特定限定一般)的证据分为两类:
The Adillah (evidences) of specifying the general are divided into two categories:
Adillah Takhsees Muttasilah(连接的限定性证据)与 Adillah Takhsees Munfasalah(分离的限定性证据)。
Adillah Takhsees Muttasilah (connecting evidences of specification) and Adillah Takhsees Munfasalah (separated evidences of specification).
"التخصيص المتصل" هو ما لا يكون مستقلاً بذاته، بل يُذكر التخصيص مع العام في نفس النص، ويرتبط معناه باللفظ العام، ويكون جزءاً من الكلام الذي يحتوي على اللفظ العام。 Translation (Simplified Chinese): "连续限定"(At-Takhsees Al-Muttasil)是指那种本身不独立存在、而是将限定(Takhsees)与“通用”(‘Aamm)一同在同一段经文(Nass)中提及的限定方式。其含义依附于通用的语词(Lafzh),它是包含通用语词的那段话语的一部分。
At-Takhsees Al-Muttasil is that which is not independent in itself but rather the Takhsees (specification) is mentioned along with the ‘Aamm (general) within the same Nass (text). Its meaning is attached to the general Lafzh and it is a part of the speech that contains the ‘Aamm Lafzh.
它有四种类型,分别是:al-Istithnaa’(排除或例外)、ash-Shart(条件)、as-Siffah(形容词/描述/属性)和al-Ghaayah(终点)。
It has four types which are: Al-Istithnaa’ (exemption or exception), Ash-Shart (the condition), As-Siffah (adjective/description/attribute) and Al-Ghaayah (end point).
A - 通过例外排除的特指(At-Takhsees by Al-Istithnaa')
A - At-Takhsees by Al-Istithnaa’ (The specification by way of exemption)
استثناء的工具(استثناء 的助词):
Adawaat Al-Istithnaa’ (particles of exception/exemption):
"通过الاستثناء(例外)进行的 تخصيص(限定)"这一用语的含义是:将例外词之后的内容,从其前面所述的范围中排除或除外。 Wait, I must follow the rules: translate faithfully, with no inserted Arabic. Corrected: 通过الاستثناء(例外)进行的تخصيص(限定),意思是将例外词之后的内容,从其前面所述的范围中排除或除外。 Corrected final: 通过الاستثناء(例外)进行的تخصيص(限定),意思是将例外词之后的内容,从其前面所述的范围中排除或除外。
The Takhsees by way of Al-Istithnaa’ (exception) means excluding or exempting that which follows the exemption from that which was before it.
示例:
Example:
安拉(SWT)说:
Allah (swt) said:
以时间起誓。人类确实处于亏损之中。除了那些信道并行善、彼此劝勉遵行真理、彼此劝勉坚忍的人(《阿斯尔》)。
By time. Verily, the human (Al-Insaan) is in loss. Except for those who have believed and done righteous deeds and advised each other to truth and advised each other to patience (Al-‘Asr).
所以,词语“Al-Insaan”(人、人类)是一个“Lafzh ‘Aamm”(通称词语),因为它是以“ال”(Al-Jinsiyah,类别定冠词)限定的单数有定名词(Mufrad Mu’arraf),因此它涵盖每一个人。真主(SWT)告知我们,每一个人都是亏损者,然后从亏损者中排除或除外了一些个体,他们不会亏损,那就是那些信道并行善(即遵照祂的命令和禁令而行)的人……这便是通过“Istithnaa’”(例外/除外)而发生的“Takhsees”(特指/限定)的一个例子。
So the Lafzh (wording) ‘Al-Insaan’ (man/human) is a Lafzh ‘Aamm because it is Mufrad Mu’arraf (defined) with ‘ال ‘Al-Jinsiyah and consequently it encompasses every human being. Allah (swt) has informed us that every human being is a loser and then excluded or exempted from those people who are losers Afraad (individual elements) that will not be losers and they are those who have believed and acted righteously (in accordance to His commands and prohibitions) … This then represents an example of the Takhsees (specification) that takes place by the Istithnaa’ (exception/exemption).
作为“例外”(Istithnaa’)有效的条件之一,是它必须与被排除的事物(Mustathnaa Minhu)相连接(Muttasil),两者之间不得有超出常规的间隔。至于那些认为例外有效,即便已经过了一个月的时间(即距离极大)也仍然有效的人,这种说法是被驳回的,且没有任何证据支持。
- It is a condition for the validity of the Istithnaa’ (exemption) for it be Muttasil (connected) to the Mustathnaa Minhu (the matter being exempted from) without there being a (more than normal) separation between them both. As for those who say that the Istithnaa’ (exception) is valid and even if the time of a month had passed (i.e. great distance) then this is rejected and has no Daleel to support it.
- 例外(Istithnaa’)回指最近的被排除对象(Mustathnaa Minhu,即例外所针对的事项)。真主至高说:
- The Istithnaa’ (exception) returns to the nearest Mustathnaa Minhu (matter which the exception is being made from). Allah Ta’Aalaa said:
除了鲁特的家人,我们必定把他们全部拯救,但他的妻子除外。我已经注定她是留在后面的人。(黑哲尔 59-60)
Except the family of Lot; indeed, we will save them all. Except his wife." We decreed that she is of those who remain behind. (Al-Hijr 59-60).
所以他的“妻子”(Imra'ah)被排除在得救者之外,却没有被排除在鲁特的家人之外,她将在灭亡者之中。——例外项(Mustathnaa)可以与被排除项(Mustathnaa Minhu)属于不同的类别(Jins)。其例证见于安拉至高的经文:
So his ‘Imra’ah’ (wife) was exempted from those who will be saved but not exempted from the family of Lut and she will be amongst those who perish. - It is permitted for the Mustathnaa (exempted matter) to be from a different Jins (kind/type) than the Mustathnaa Minhu (matter the exemption is being made from). An example of that is found in the Qawl of Allah Ta’Aalaa:
当我对天使们说:"你们向阿丹叩头"时,他们都叩头了,唯有易卜劣厮除外(《伊斯拉》61)。
And [mention] when We said to the angles: "Prostrate to Adam," and they prostrated, except for Iblees (Al-Israa’ 61).
这是因为易卜劣斯并不属于天使(马拉伊卡)之列,正如安拉(SWT)所说:
And that is because Iblees was not from amongst the Malaa’ikah (angels) as Allah (swt) said:
当我对天使们说"你们向阿丹叩头"时,他们都叩头了,唯独易卜劣厮除外。他是精灵之一,违背了他主的命令(《洞窟章》50)。
And [mention] when We said to the angels, "Prostrate to Adam," and they prostrated, except for Iblees. He was of the jinn and disobeyed the command of his Lord (Al-Kahf 50).
因此,易卜劣厮并非来自天使,而是来自精灵(Jinn)。 当例外语(Istithnaa')出现在相互连接或并列(Ma'toof)的句子之后时,例外语适用于所有已提及的内容,除非有证据(Daleel)表明另有所指。有学者认为,例外语仅返回到最后一句(或最后一个陈述),除非有证据表明其具有普遍性或涵盖了所有句子。其例证是安拉至高的圣言:
Iblees is therefore not from the Malaa’ikah but rather from the Jinn. - When the Istithnaa’ (exception) comes after sentences that are connected or joined (Ma’toof) to one another, then the Istithnaa’ returns to all (that has been mentioned) as long as there is no Daleel to specify other than that. Some have held the view that the Istithnaa’ (exception) returns back to the last sentence (or statement) alone unless the Daleel indicates generality or that it covers all of them. An example of this is the Qawl of Allah Ta’Aalaa
那些指控贞洁妇女、却拿不出四名证人的人,你们要抽他们八十鞭,并且永远不接受他们的证言,他们确实是法希格(Fasiqun,即说谎者、悖逆者、违抗真主的人)。除非他们此后悔罪并行善,(这样的人)真主确实是至赦的,至慈的(《光明章》4-5)。
And those who accuse chaste women, and produce not four witnesses, flog them with eighty stripes, and reject their testimony forever, they indeed are the Fasiqun (liars, rebellious, disobedient to Allah). Except those who repent thereafter and do righteous deeds, (for such) verily, Allah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful (An-Noor 4-5).
根据较为有力(或较为可信)的观点,此处的例外语(Istithnaa')仅指向“Faasiqeen”(犯罪者/败坏者),而不指向鞭刑或接受其证言。
The Istithnaa’ (exception) here returns to the Faasiqeen alone and not to the flogging or acceptance of testimony, according to the preponderant (or stronger) opinion.
B – 限定性描述(At-Takhsees Bi-s-Siffah)
B – At-Takhsees Bi-s-Siffah (The specification by the attribute/description)
若“عام”(概括性的)与一个“صفة”(属性、描述、形容)相连或相关联,那么它就由该属性所限定,除该属性所涵盖者之外的一切都被排除在外。这如同先知穆罕默德ﷺ的这句话:
If the ‘Aamm (general) is connected or linked to a Siffah (attribute/description/adjective) then it is specified by it and all other than it is excluded from it. This is like in the statement of the Messenger of Allah (saw):
在每一头放牧的(Saa’imah)骆驼(Ibil)……
In (respect to) every free grazing (Saa’imah) camel (Ibil)…
他关于“Saa’imah”(放牧的)的表述,是一个形容词(Siffah),它与“‘Aamm”(普遍的)相连,而这个“‘Aamm”就是“‘Ibil”(骆驼)这个词,后面跟着“Kull”(每一个)。因此它涵盖了所有的骆驼;但由于它与“放牧的”这一形容词相连,所有不是放牧的骆驼都被排除在这一普遍性之外,这些就是用草料喂养的骆驼。由此表明,用草料喂养的骆驼不需缴纳天课,天课只应由那些自由放牧、在草场上生活并以草为食的骆驼来承担。
His statement ‘Saa’imah’ (free grazing) is a Siffah (adjective) that has been connected to the ‘Aamm (general) which is the Lafzh ‘Ibil’ (camel) that follows the word ‘Kull’ (every). So it covers all of the camels however due to being connected or linked to a Siffah, the wording ‘Free grazing’, all camels that are not free grazing are taken out from this generality and these are the camels which are fed with fodder. It therefore indicates that there is no Zakaah upon the foddered camels but rather Zakaah is only due upon those camels which graze freely, live and feed off the pastures.
在以“صفة”(描述/属性)进行限定时,其有效的条件是:该描述须与被描述之物(“موصوف”)相连,或与所关联的裁定(“حكم”)相连。
The condition for the validity of specifying by the Siffah (description/attribute) is that it is connected to the Mawsoof (described thing/matter) or to the connecting Hukm.
示例:
Example:
他的圣言(SWT):
His Qawl (swt):
以下女子,你们不得与她们结婚:你们的母亲、你们的女儿、你们的姊妹、你们父亲的姊妹、你们母亲的姊妹、你们兄弟的女儿、你们姊妹的女儿、乳养你们的乳母、与你们有乳姊妹关系的女子、你们妻子的母亲、你们妻子所生而在你们监护之下的继女(前提是你们已与她们的母亲同房);若你们尚未与她们的母亲同房,则娶她们并无罪过。你们亲生儿子的妻子也不得娶;同时娶两姊妹为妻也不得,但已经过去的除外。{真主是至赦的,是至慈的。}(妇女章 23)
Forbidden to you (for marriage) are: your mothers, your daughters, your sisters, your father's sisters, your mother's sisters, your brother's daughters, your sister's daughters, your foster mother who gave you suck, your foster milk suckling sisters, your wives' mothers, your step daughters under your guardianship, born of your women (Nisaa’ikum) to whom you have gone in - but there is no sin on you if you have not gone in them (to marry their daughters), - the wives of your sons who (spring) from your own loins, and two sisters in wedlock at the same time, except for what has already passed; verily, Allah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful (An-Nisaa’ 23).
这里的词语"نِسَائِكُمْ"(你们的妻子们/你们的女人们)是"عام"(通称)的,因为它是复数并且加上了代词(إضافة)。这个"عام"随后被其后所提到的"صفة"(形容/限定语)"اللَّاتِي دَخَلْتُم بِهِنَّ"(你们与之同房的)所限定。因此,禁止娶继女的规定仅限于那些已与之同房的妻子的女儿,而不包括已订立婚约但尚未同房的女子。
Here the Lafzh ‘Nisaa’ikum’ (your women) is ‘Aamm because it is a plural that is added to a pronoun (Idaafah). This ‘Aamm (general) has then been specified by the Siffah (adjective/description) that is mentioned following it ‘To whom you have gone in’. Therefore, the Tahreem (prohibition) of marrying the step-daughter is restricted to the daughters of the wives that had been entered into while it does not encompass and cover the women which has been contracted (in marriage) but the marriage has yet to have been consummated.
C – At-Takhsees Bi-sh-Shart(以条件限定)
C – At-Takhsees Bi-sh-Shart (the specification by the condition)
条件句的工具(أدوات الشرط,即"Adawaat")有很多,包括:
The Adawaat (particles) of the Shart (condition) are numerous and they include:
安拉至高无上说:
Allah Ta’Aalaa said:
在你们妻子所遗留的财产中,如果她们没有子女,你们可得一半。
In that which your wives leave, your share is a half if (إن (they have no child (An-Nisaa’ 12).
丈夫的继承份额由"Shart"(条件)规定:若妻子去世后未留下子女,无论男孩还是女孩,丈夫可继承妻子遗产的一半。
The Shart (condition) has specified the inheritance of the husband with half of what his wife leaves behind if she does not leave behind her, following her death, a child, whether male or female.
因此,丈夫继承一半的情况仅限于没有子女的情形。然而,如果她有子女,继承情况就会不同,丈夫则只能得到遗产剩余部分的四分之一(即“At-Tarkah”)。Shart(条件)将原本包含在言辞之中的内容排除在外,而如果没有这个条件,这些内容本会留在言辞之内。这就像这样一句话:“Akrim Al-Mujaahideen In Fatahoo Al-Hisn”(如果穆贾希德攻下堡垒,就尊敬他们)。如果句式中没有“إن”(如果)这一形式,那么对穆贾希德的尊敬就会普遍适用于所有穆贾希德。然而,“إن”的加入排除了那些没有攻下堡垒的人。
The inheritance of half is therefore restricted to the case of the non-existence of a child. If however she has a child then the inheritance would differ and the husband would then get a quarter of what is left (At-Tarkah). The Shart, as such, excludes from the speech that which if the Shart had not been there, would have remained within it. This is like the statement: “Akrim Al-Mujaahideen In Fatahoo Al-Hisn” (Honour the Mujaahideen if they conquer the fortress). If it had not been in the Seeghah (form) of ‘إن) ‘if) then the Ikraam (honouring) would have been general for all of the Mujaahideen. However, the insertion of ‘إن ‘takes out those who do not conquer the fortress.
安拉的使者ﷺ说:
And the Messenger of Allah (saw) said:
如果你们中有人打算求娶某位妇女,并且他能够从她身上看到让他感到满意的部分,那么就让他这样做吧。(艾布·达乌德在其《逊南》中记载)
If one of you (intends) to engage the woman (and) then he was capable of seeing (that) from her of that which pleases him, then let him do that (Abu Dawud in his Sunan).
这一条件使男子在想与该女子订婚时,可以看她身体中他能够看到的任何部分,因此,这一条件为男子看女子的私处('Awrah)这一禁令设立了例外,即当其目的是求婚时。所以,这段圣训将男子看女子私处的一般性禁令('Umoom,普遍性)限定于那些不打算求娶她的人。
This condition makes it permissible for the man to look at any part of the body of the woman that he is capable of seeing if he wishes to engage her for marriage and so this Shart (condition) has made an exception to the prohibition of the man looking at the ‘Awrah of the women in this case when it is for the purpose of engaging her in marriage. The Hadeeth has therefore specified the ‘Umoom (generality) of the Hurmah (prohibition) of the man looking at the ‘Awrah of the woman to other than those who wish to engage her.
D – 以终点限定(即“直到”的含义)的特指(At-Takhsees Bi-l-Ghaayah)
D – At-Takhsees Bi-l-Ghaayah (The specification by the end point (i.e. the meaning of until))
"غاية" 的形式有两种措辞(lafẓ),分别是:
The forms of the Ghaayah are two Lafzhs (wordings) which are:
ِ(إلى)和(حتى)(直到):如果这两个词所表示的表达式包含在一般性的言辞之中,那么它们之后的内容就被排除在外。其后的律定(Hukm)必须与其前的律定相反。
ِ( Ilaa and Hattaa/to/until). If any of these two worded expressions are included within the general speech, then what comes after them is excluded. The Hukm of what follows must be contrary to the Hukm that was before it.
示例:
Example:
安拉(SWT)说:
Allah (swt) said:
(然后)洗你们的脸,洗你们的手臂直到手肘。(《筵席章》6)
(Then) wash your faces and your forearms to (Ilaa) the elbows (Al-Maa’idah 6).
“Aidiyakum”这一措辞是一个泛指(ʿĀmm)的词,包括从肩部直到手指的整个手臂。然而,这一泛指已被安拉的话语“Ilaa-l-Maraafiq”(到肘部)所限定。因此,所要求和规定的是:从手指处开始洗至肘部。如此,“Ilaa”(到)作为表示终点的虚词(Ḥarf al-Ghāyah),将其后的部分排除在清洗范围之外。 此外,需要特别指出的是,就这一问题而言,伊斯兰教法原则(Qāʿidah Sharʿiyyah)所说的“凡是不完成义务便无法完成的事,那它本身也是义务”(Maa Laa Yatimm ul-Waajib Illaa Bihi FaHuwa Waajib),使清洗肘部的一小部分成为必须,目的是确保手臂清洗至肘部的义务得以完成。 另一个例子:
The Lafzh ‘Aidiyakum’ (hands/forearms) is a Lafzh ‘Aamm and includes the ‘Yad’ from the shoulders until the fingers. However, the ‘Aamm has been specified by His Qawl: “Ilaa-l-Maraafiq” (to (or until) the elbows). Consequently, what is required and has been requested is to wash from the hand that which is from the fingers to the elbows. In that way ‘Ilaa’ (To/until), which is a Harf (particle of) Al-Ghaayah, has excluded that which comes after that, from the washing. However, as an extra point of note, in respect to this issue specifically, the Qaa’idah Ash-Shar’iyah (Shar’iyah principle) that states: ‘Maa Laa Yatimm ul-Waajib Illaa Bihi FaHuwa Waajib’ (That which the Waajib is not fulfilled except with it is a Waajib) has made the washing of a bit or part of the elbows Waajib and that is in order to ensure the washing of the Yad (arm) to the elbows is fulfilled. Another example:
安拉至高无上说:
Allah Ta’Aalaa said:
请与那些不信真主、不信末日、不以真主和祂的使者所禁止的为禁物、也不遵奉真理之教的有经典者中的人作战,直到他们心甘情愿地缴纳人头税,并且俯首称臣。(忏悔章 9:29)
Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the Jizyah willingly while they are humbled (At-Taubah 29).
“الَّذِينَ”这个词表示普遍性(العموم),因为这一关系代词指的是复数,而真主命令我们普遍地与不信真主的人作战。随后又接上了终止词(الغاية)的助词“حَتَّى”,由此排除了那些不需要与之作战的人,他们就是缴纳人头税(الجزية)并服从伊斯兰统治权威的人。这样的人,因为已经缴纳了人头税,就不再被作战。
The Lafzh ‘Alladheena’ (those) establishes al-‘Umoom (generality) because the Ism Mawsool (relative pronoun) indicates a Jam’un (plural) and Allah has commanded us to fight those who do not believe in Allah in a general manner. This was then followed by the particle (‘Adaat) of Al-Ghaayah ‘Hattaa’ and so it excluded from those whom it is obligatory to fight and they are those who give the Jizyah and submit to the authority of Islam. Those, who do that, are not fought as a result of their giving of the Jizyah.
因此,"Aamm"(一般性)中"不信真主者"这一泛指词的特指(Takhsees),是通过限定词"Ghaayah"及其形式"Hattaa"(直到)而发生的。"Hattaa"(直到)之后的内容,在判断(Hukm)上与"Hattaa"之前的内容相反。这正是在"Hattaa"之前的内容属于"Aamm"(一般性)的情况下,其后的内容在判断上从其前的内容中被排除出去。
Consequently, the Takhsees of the ‘Aamm, which is ‘those who don’t believe in Allah’, has occurred by way of the Ghaayah and its form ‘Hattaa’ and so what comes after the ‘Hattaa’ (until) is contrary, in respect to its Hukm, to what is before ‘Hattaa’ (until). This is where that which came after it was taken out of that which was before it in respect to the Hukm, in the case where what was before it was ‘Aamm (general).